Username:

Password:

Wii Fit Insults 10-year-old Girl

on 17.05.2008 at 10:40 User Icon Posted by Jorge Ba-oh (jb)
Tag Tags: Wii Fit, BMI, Nintendo, 10-year-old
A young girl was shunned as "fat" by Wii Fit despite being active and of a healthy weight and height for her age.

According to The Daily Mail, Obesity experts have eaten Nintendo alive after the Wii Fit software calculated the 10-year old as fat. When starting up the board uses a player's height and weight to calculate their levels of BMI placing them in categories like "underweight" and "fat".

A father revealed his daughter's embarrassment when she was labelled as fat, in spite of being 4ft 9in tall and weighing 6 stone. "She is solidly built but not fat. She was devastated to be called fat and we had to work hard to convince her she isn't.

I know it is just a game but we already have to worry about young girls starving themselves to look like magazine models and now we have a game that tells them they're fat. This to me is very worrying."

Tam Fry, of the National Obesity Forum, has claimed the BMI measurement was completely misleading "BMI is far from perfect but with children it simply should not be used. I would be very concerned if children were using this game and I believe it should carry a warning for parents."

Nintendo have denied a warning for the game, but still apologised to any customers "offended by the in-game terminology" as part of the BMI system. "Wii Fit is still capable of measuring the BMI for people aged between two and 20 but the resulting figures may not be entirely accurate for younger age groups due to varying levels of development."

It looks like Nintendo invented the word "fat" it seems...

Do you feel Wii Fit gives an accurate representation of one's health and fitness level, or should it be seen as a bit of fun?

Thanks to C3 reader Linkyshinks for the tip.

More on Wii Fit (Wii)

Show All

Developer: Nintendo EAD

Publisher: Nintendo

Genre: Other

Players: 8

C3 Score
9
Reader Score (10 Votes)
9
Rate
add to collection
add to wishlist

Please post your comments below | Submit News Tip | Archive
Add a comment to this Story
Please login to post a comment :), or sign up for a free acccount.


artmonkey Reply Quote #1 

artmonkey

 L58 Hylian Knight
'[he's] alright' - Robsy on artmonkey

Offline

Number of comments 1306 396 Number of comments 09.05.2006 Wi-Fi Name none

The Balance Board's actual words were "Well, well, you are a little fatty bombatty aren't you? There's a nice pork pie in the fridge, why don't you go get it and see if you can balance it on your nose? There's a good little chunky monkey."
Play Banjo-Kazooie.

I want serious new features.
on 17.05.2008 at 10:48 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

jb Reply Quote #2 

jb

 Founder/Admin
Brawl. Music. Orgasmic!

Online!

Number of comments 14031 880 Number of comments 04.01.2003 Wi-Fi Name jbcubed3.

artmonkey said:
The Balance Board's actual words were "Well, well, you are a little fatty bombatty aren't you? There's a nice pork pie in the fridge, why don't you go get it and see if you can balance it on your nose? There's a good little chunky monkey."


Oh artmonkey, where would we be without you! SmilieSmilie

Mmmmm... pork pies!

jb(at)cubed3.com
on 17.05.2008 at 10:49 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Wiill Reply Quote #3 

Wiill

 L11 Kooper Trooper

Offline

Number of comments 102 24 Number of comments 07.05.2007 Wi-Fi Name Wiill

Well quite clearly Wii Fit is not accurate, but in particular it is not accurate for children. Of course, both this and Wii Sports ages are for adults anyway.

Depressing that a ten year old would care so much about her weight anyway. This is the typical Daily Mail thing of digging up anything they can about video games. Don't they have more important things to wrote about than random anecdotal evidence?

Still, Nintendo should have been more careful. I haven't got Wii Fit, though, so I'm not aware: are there any in-game warnings about the fact that it's not accurate for under 18s? There were in Sports...
on 17.05.2008 at 10:49 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

jb Reply Quote #4 

jb

 Founder/Admin
Brawl. Music. Orgasmic!

Online!

Number of comments 14031 880 Number of comments 04.01.2003 Wi-Fi Name jbcubed3.

That's true - Nintendo definitely need to be more careful, especially when its to do with weight and the current trend amongst women these days to look as scarily skinny as possible.

Not sure about documentation as I haven't gotten Wii Fit yet, but I'm hoping they've got something in the manual about it at least.

I think if people are shelling out £70 (or more) for it, then they'd at least expect it to work really well for their moneys.

( Edited 17.05.2008 10:54 by jb )


jb(at)cubed3.com
on 17.05.2008 at 10:53 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Birdo Is A Tranny Reply Quote #5 

Birdo Is A Tranny

 L44 Nuriak Warrior
Birdo is a tranny it's on wiki!!!

Offline

Number of comments 745 51 Number of comments 17.07.2007 Wi-Fi Name Ian

A young girl was shunned as “fat”


fat
fat
fat
Fat
Fat
FAT!
FAT!!!
FATTY!!!
on 17.05.2008 at 11:05 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Demoni Rakkausenkeli Reply Quote #6 

Demoni Rakkausenkeli

 L24 Crawlton Guard
Mie oon rakkausenkeli!

Offline

Number of comments 260 11 Number of comments 03.04.2008 Wi-Fi Name none

she is most likely a fat-thinking-she-is-a-skinny-girl
on 17.05.2008 at 11:36 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

zcollvee Reply Quote #7 

zcollvee

 L58 Hylian Knight
I deserve you'r star! Har!

Offline

Number of comments 1349 178 Number of comments 15.12.2006 Wi-Fi Name Zaf

this was bound to happen
Animal Crossing Movie[WATCH]
please do not mind my post. its in wrong english and not capitalized. it also may have advertisements. Smilie
on 17.05.2008 at 11:38 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

irfman Reply Quote #8 

irfman

 L22 Captain Blue
Le Enfants Terribl

Offline

Number of comments 232 24 Number of comments 23.03.2006 Wi-Fi Name none

Well obviously the cake wasn't a lie for the girl Smilie
on 17.05.2008 at 11:39 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

aburnett Reply Quote #9 

aburnett

 L8 Floating Lakitu

Offline

Number of comments 79 21 Number of comments 30.09.2007 Wi-Fi Name none

Girl of 10 is six stone?

Thats quite fat to me.

I'm double her age and only eight.

Yeah, I know what Wii Fit would stay about me... *awaits criticism*
on 17.05.2008 at 12:08 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

iSimon Reply Quote #10 

iSimon

 L80 Dark Link
Caterpie pwns Weedle

Offline

Number of comments 3010 364 Number of comments 20.09.2006 Wi-Fi Name <(^o^)>

I'm 5'10 and only weigh 1 stone more than her.....she's fat.
Dojo - (King of Brackets)

My Manly Hugs List
PK Mongoose
zcollvee
BlueRocks
SuperLink
No Avatar
iangennery
Smells like cheese
Philcsf
L
Ikana
TheEvilShyGuy
A_man_92

This thread makes no sense
on 17.05.2008 at 12:16 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

SuperLink Reply Quote #11 

SuperLink

 C3 Mod
Go Team Sea Slug!

Online!

Number of comments 14170 755 Number of comments 19.01.2005 Wi-Fi Name Link / SuperLink9

Lol. Wii Fit is pretty harsh on what's classed as "obesse" from trailers I've seen. It's pretty ridiculous. I think this is hilarious. XD Females in our country are so paranoid!

Even though that does sound quite heavy. I'm 17 and I think I'm only 6 or 7 stone. :S

But then again I'm a human stick. My weight is only my bones, my muscules and skin don't weigh anything in the slightest.

~League of Kings - King - "The One"~ | May the League of Kings always reign supreme!

C3 SHENMUE III DECADE | 18.06.2009
YouTube Profile: Super Slick Bros are GO! + Super Smash Bros YouTube Group
~Brawl Friend Code: 4081-6946-5924
~
BUY OKAMI
on 17.05.2008 at 12:30 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Modplan Man Reply Quote #12 

Modplan Man

 L75 King Dedede
Hairy Mary

Call me Ryan

Offline

Number of comments 2541 494 Number of comments 23.09.2006 Wi-Fi Name none

LOL at "solidly built".

It's odd that parents didn't realise that the game might tell her this, considering that's the kind of fecking game it is.
Have a console problem? - See here



Nudity, Strong Language, Violence

Tickle me pink with a wink
on 17.05.2008 at 12:36 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

D_prOdigy Reply Quote #13 

D_prOdigy

 L15 Golden Torizo

Offline

Number of comments 149 14 Number of comments 23.03.2008 Wi-Fi Name D_prOdigy

According to The Daily Mail


That's when I stopped reading...
on 17.05.2008 at 12:41 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

meowthemouse Reply Quote #14 

meowthemouse

 L3 Gooba Guard
M30W

Offline

Number of comments 27 21 Number of comments 10.02.2008 Wi-Fi Name none

irfman said:
Well obviously the cake wasn't a lie for the girl Smilie


haha xD
"Sony always wins baby.. Sony always wins.." - Chad Warden on pstripple
Brawl FC : 2191 - 6919 - 2772
on 17.05.2008 at 13:32 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

squeek Reply Quote #15 

squeek

 L16 Guardian Dragon

Offline

Number of comments 151 32 Number of comments 28.03.2007 Wi-Fi Name ian

They haven't included a picture of her, which is quite telling I feel.
on 17.05.2008 at 13:47 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Fenton Reply Quote #16 

Fenton

 L83 Hyper Knuckles

Offline

Number of comments 3385 150 Number of comments 03.07.2004 Wi-Fi Name none

squeek said:
They haven't included a picture of her, which is quite telling I feel.


paedophileSmilie

No seriously though, I think any sane person can tell whether they are overweight or not.

Not that it was something I ever worried about at 10 years old. Parents should bring the kids up correctly so that they arent brought up by the media.
on 17.05.2008 at 13:58 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Darkflame Reply Quote #17 

Darkflame

 L51 Regular Knuckles

Offline

Number of comments 950 64 Number of comments 07.12.2004 Wi-Fi Name none

BMI shouldnt be used for ANYONE.

Its a flawed concept, and doctors and scientists know it.
We should be more concerned its still used by the government then Nintendo though.
When you hear all this "X amount of the UK" is fat or such, its based on BMI.
on 17.05.2008 at 15:36 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

iSimon Reply Quote #18 

iSimon

 L80 Dark Link
Caterpie pwns Weedle

Offline

Number of comments 3010 364 Number of comments 20.09.2006 Wi-Fi Name <(^o^)>

OMFG I WAS INSULTED BY A VIDEO GAME !!!11!!!

*slit wrist*
Dojo - (King of Brackets)

My Manly Hugs List
PK Mongoose
zcollvee
BlueRocks
SuperLink
No Avatar
iangennery
Smells like cheese
Philcsf
L
Ikana
TheEvilShyGuy
A_man_92

This thread makes no sense
on 17.05.2008 at 15:54 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

The cheese. Reply Quote #19 

The cheese.

 L100 Eternal Master
A star or two would be nice, for anyone reading this ;-)

Online!

Number of comments 5118 270 Number of comments 02.07.2004 Wi-Fi Name none

SuperLink said:

But then again I'm a human stick. My weight is only my bones, my muscules and skin don't weigh anything in the slightest.


I'm right there with you! No fat, no muscle, just skin and bone...and a huge penis of course...and a big brain...and a sense of modesty, although I don't think modesty weighs much to be honest.

It doesn't matter what I eat or what exercise I do (or don't do), I don't gain weight. But I'm happy with who I am.

Anywho, the rule of thumb for kids is that if other kids tell you you're fat, then you're fat. If they don't then you're probably okay (unless they're all saying it behind your back).
This is my very small signature. I hope it's not too big.
on 17.05.2008 at 16:29 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

Birdo Is A Tranny Reply Quote #20 

Birdo Is A Tranny

 L44 Nuriak Warrior
Birdo is a tranny it's on wiki!!!

Offline

Number of comments 745 51 Number of comments 17.07.2007 Wi-Fi Name Ian

It doesn't matter what I eat or what exercise I do (or don't do), I don't gain weight.


Same! I just think I have an exteremely high metabolism, because I'm one of the lazyiest people I know.

Anywho, the rule of thumb for kids is that if other kids tell you you're fat, then you're fat.


Does that rule still apply in anorexic camp? Smilie
on 17.05.2008 at 16:52 Games | Blog | Wii Codes | Message Me

Tools | Top | Bottom

joehyland Reply Quote #21 

joehyland

 L2 Toad

Offline

Number of comments 14 21 Number of comments 23.06.2007 Wi-Fi Name JosephHyland

Perhaps she should've been made aware that Wii Fit tells it like it is. 4'9, 10 and 6 stone. I know 13 year olds with that weight. Smilie
on 17.05.2008 at 17:09 Games | Blog | Wii Codes