News: Nintendo Responds to Smash Bros. Disc Issues Page 1

russraine 28.06.2008#1

Should Nintendo have taken better precautions to ensure Wii owners who have waited months are satisfied?

Well if the dust/dirt theory from Nintendo is true, I can't think what they could have done short of asking for everyone to send their Wii in for cleaning last month so that it would be ready in time for Brawl.

D_prOdigy 28.06.2008#2

It was a significant manufacturing error on Nintendo's part when they were designing Wii. No proper lense should have difficulty reading dual-layered DVD discs. Why Nintendo assumed no Wii games would be released on such format is beyond me.

Topguy4 28.06.2008#3

I really dont care. Its not even an issue.

HazukiSan 28.06.2008#4

Topguy4 said:
I really dont care. Its not even an issue.

How can you possibly say it's not an issue? The fact the console has an inherent flaw that restricts certain discs being read (any decent lens should read dual layered DVD's, even if the lens is a bit dusty) shows up once again the cost cutting that happened in Wii production.

evilflame 28.06.2008#5

Then again nintendo were looking for a cheap, console for the consumers. So that it was the most affordable console around. Although, this flaw does ask certain questions of why they didn't think any game would need to go beyound a standard disk. They probably thought if any needed it they could just make a game a 2-disk set like in the gamecube era.

HazukiSan 28.06.2008#6

evilflame said:
Then again nintendo were looking for a cheap, console for the consumers. So that it was the most affordable console around. Although, this flaw does ask certain questions of why they didn't think any game would need to go beyound a standard disk. They probably thought if any needed it they could just make a game a 2-disk set like in the gamecube era.

True, it reeks of a console built to a budget, a very very tight budget and yet it'll get no negative press for it.

Microsoft did the same and they had the red ring fiasco costing them billions. Sony went the other way and built with cost not an object, still get stick for too expensive a console. Nintendo built a cheap console, have problems and get away with it? No wonder the company is getting away with producing absolute rubbish for the console, it's formerly very picky fanbase is now accepting absolutely anything from them.

Modplan Man 28.06.2008#7

Unless you have stuff to show this'll cost them billions or is on anywhere near the scale of RROD, then go ahead.

Will just have to wait and see how many it genuinely affects. It might be a small percentage, might not be. Anyone know how widespread it is across other forums?

People keep saying they need a reason to dust off their Wii - maybe this'll force them to get the hoover in it once in a while. Are there nozzle attachments that'll fit inside the disc slot?

EdEN 28.06.2008#8

Never had a problem with SSBB loading on my console and it has been doing so for months.

I believe Nintendo is telling the truth about this and dirt CAN get into te disc since the Wii has a loading slot and not a tray. Just take better care of your console and clean your house regularly.

JoshSL 28.06.2008#9

I think it's Nintendo's way of saying smoking is bad for you :3

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Sifu Avenger 28.06.2008#10

Of course. Dust are a very tiny particles, it can make technology unable to read the files. Dust is one of Technologies most weakness. Unless you have plastic that protects it anyway.

Sifu Avenger said: Hey, as long as you know all my shadow attacks! (Laughing) Hero Natliusx said: I once died, I also once was reborn to give all my souls to live. (Clenched his hands)

Birdo Is A Tranny 28.06.2008#11

I'm thinking, that almost everyone will need to use this service eventually. Think about it, if it's not dusty now it'll have to be a year or six months down the road (unless you clean the inside of the wii somehow yourself). It's better to happen now than to happen the day you get animal crossing or pikmin 3.

L 28.06.2008#12

SuperLink said:
I think it's Nintendo's way of saying smoking is bad for you :3

I don't smoke and I've still got this problem.

shiptoncraig 28.06.2008#13

shows up once again the cost cutting that happened in Wii production.

Once again? Are we talking GPU meltdown due to WC24?

True, it reeks of a console built to a budget, a very very tight budget and yet it\'ll get no negative press for it.

Not on the scale of the 360\'s mountainous errors though, not by a long shot. In any case, browse about and you\'ll see people ridiculing this \"excuse\". The ridicule just isn\'t to 360 standard and deservedly so.

it\'s formerly very picky fanbase is now accepting absolutely anything from them.

Look around and you\'ll see that Nintendo\'s former fanbase, i.e. some of us, are not happy with the rubbish that is being released on the Wii. It\'s the new fanbase who don\'t care.

( Edited 28.06.2008 19:09 by shiptoncraig )

360 Gamertag: shiptoncraig
PSN: shiptoncraig
Steam: Guess what?

JoshSL 28.06.2008#14

L said:

I don't smoke and I've still got this problem.

Yeah it's also just bad luck in a lot of cases. Smilie

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Echoes221 28.06.2008#15

My wii is fine, though ive only had it since september.
Ive had no problems, the only one was GH3 where it failed to read the disk or boot it up properly but thats been sorted out by the new remastered disks.

Stulaw 29.06.2008#16

I don't have the problem, and I've had my wii since lauch.

Follow Me on twitter :: @Stulaw90 || My Youtube || Backloggery
NNID: Stulaw

Sifu Avenger 29.06.2008#17

Geez, that is most horrific thing i ever seen. That is most stupid thing i ever saw too. Why didnt UK figured it out that eariler so they can prevent it from plaguing more damn SSBB? This is piece of shit SSBB, i hate SSBB now, lets punish UK Smilie Smilie Smilie

Sifu Avenger said: Hey, as long as you know all my shadow attacks! (Laughing) Hero Natliusx said: I once died, I also once was reborn to give all my souls to live. (Clenched his hands)

Flynnie 29.06.2008#18

I'd like to say that i dont have the problem but after inserting some discs my Wii makes a very dodgy noise indeed. I dread to think what kinda noise it will make when Brawl goes in.

Just fix it the old Nintendo way and blow it.

Isnt there some kinda disc that you can insert to clean the lens? Man, shipping the thing off to Nintendo seems very inconvienient. The thing has only been out for 18 months or so and if these problems are evident then do we need to send it off every 18 months or so to get it cleaned to play Smash or other dual layered discs. Absoultely shockinG!

GinnyN 29.06.2008#19

For all Eurepean people:

This problem exists since the release of Smash in Japan. In America they had the some problem. It's not only the cigars, also live in heavy contaminated places will also affect.

The lens of the Wii is smaller than the usual one, for the size of the Wii itself, for that the lens it's a bit more sensible to dust. Here's in Chile, for example, the only ones with problems were a little group from Santiago, the most contaminated place in my country. I live in Valpara�so, the second most contaminated place in Chile, and I don't have any problems with reading the game. A normal lens anyway will stop reading stuff thanks to dust someday, and I had some problems with reading games (Kingdom Hearts II) from a PS2.

The lens of a Wii is different from a normal one not because it's cheaper, because it's smaller. While it's true it's their fault, they offer a good way for Smash owners to somewhat fix the problem, even in my country, where they just have an official distributor. And it's true, it's from a small percentage.

The only way for take better precautions is, somehow, change all the Wiis with this problem and right away clean it, but, how? You have no idea if the problem will exist without a Smash Copy and clean all the Wiis since launch to the moment they change the lens (They will do it, I'm sure) and that is pretty darn expensive. Appart, anyone will actually send the Wii in advance for prepare it for Brawl if they don't have any idea if they will have the trouble after all? Nintendo hates lose money. If they are actually offering a service like this one and free is because it's an actual minimal percentage.

@HazukiSan
Nintendo Fans are still picky, trust me. If in Japan they don't yell about this problem, this service will never exists in first place. They make it official even in places they don't have actual presence. That I call good service. And, appart, in Nintendo are humans, they can commit mistakes (It's not a Ring of Death after all)

Edit this post:

For all Eurepean people:

This problem exists since the release of Smash in Japan. In America they had the some problem. It's not only the cigars, also live in heavy contaminated places will also affect.

The lens of the Wii is smaller than the usual one, for the size of the Wii itself, for that the lens it's a bit more sensible to dust. Here's in Chile, for example, the only ones with problems were a little group from Santiago, the most contaminated place in my country. I live in Valpara�so, the second most contaminated place in Chile, and I don't have any problems with reading the game. A normal lens anyway will stop reading stuff thanks to dust someday, and I had some problems with reading games (Kingdom Hearts II) from a PS2.

The lens of a Wii is different from a normal one not because it's cheaper, because it's smaller. While it's true it's their fault, they offer a good way for Smash owners to somewhat fix the problem, even in my country, where they just have an official distributor. And it's true, it's from a small percentage.

The only way for take better precautions is, somehow, change all the Wiis with this problem and right away clean it, but, how? You have no idea if the problem will exist without a Smash Copy and clean all the Wiis since launch to the moment they change the lens (They will do it, I'm sure) and that is pretty darn expensive. Appart, anyone will actually send the Wii in advance for prepare it for Brawl if they don't have any idea if they will have the trouble after all? Nintendo hates lose money. If they are actually offering a service like this one and free is because it's an actual minimal percentage.

@HazukiSan
Nintendo Fans are still picky, trust me. If in Japan they don't yell about this problem, this service will never exists in first place. They make it official even in places they don't have actual presence. That I call good service. And, appart, in Nintendo are humans, they can commit mistakes (It's not a Ring of Death after all)

Save Changes Cancel Full Edit

Kangaroo_Kid 29.06.2008#20

I don't think it would have a huge deal to do with building the console to a budget, it wouldn't have made any noticable difference to manufacturing or retail pricing to just put in a better lens.

Phoenom 29.06.2008#21

My Wii is completely fine. Sounds like a banshee when I'm playing Brawl though. Smilie

BrawlBumBoy 29.06.2008#22

I just love how Nintendo isnt Microsoft. If it was, it would cost money. I know that people want to play Brawl but at least its not lack of Brawl and lack of money. Thank god it hasnt happened to me, I guess it would be a different story if it had though Smilie

My pictures wont appear so heres a smiley

Kangaroo_Kid 29.06.2008#23

I still have and play my SNES a heck of a lot and it still works pretty much perfectly. The wiring in the power adaptor is a bit fucked but that's it.

The fact that my decade-and-a-half year old console still works fine while "a small percentage" of Wiis have to be shipped away to be cleaned so they can play one of Nintendo's biggest flagship titles just shows how Nintendo have changed.

evilflame 30.06.2008#24

In many cases it's bad luck, some is good luck.

I mean i have had my Wii since launch and i've had no problems what-so-ever.

And the same when i bought my xbox [original] It was supposed to have an error in the console making it possibly catch on fire, yet we never had that problem. So in many cases it can be just luck of things.

It's like saying in our house that is fairly clean, and we have never smoked, we could still get the problem. It just depends.

Zapp 30.06.2008#25

I dont have any problems... *thanks the looord*

But the loading times sometime are take a few seconds...?!?!

I see all these people insulting the Nintendo corporation because of the lack of mature content. Yet there is something about Nintendo (at least their games) that strikes a certain unadulterated feeling of joy!!! Pokemon Y - 1048-9263-5562

Show Spoiler

or sign in with...

Nintendo Responds to Smash Bros. Disc Issues

Super Smash Bros. Brawl (Wii)

Comment on this article

Comments

Subscribe to this topic