Third Parties Surprised By Wii MotionPlus
on 23.07.2008 at 12:29
Posted by Jorge Ba-oh (jb)
Comments: 20
Reads: 1237
Tags:
Wii, MotionPlus, Nintendo, E3
Posted by Jorge Ba-oh (jb)
Comments: 20
Reads: 1237
Tags:
Wii, MotionPlus, Nintendo, E3 Recent News
Nintendo's latest peripheral for Wii, the MotionPlus, came as a surprise to the gaming public. It seems that a fair few third parties also fell into that category.
During E3 the king of console add-ons revealed an advancement for motion control for Wii players: the MotionPlus. The plugin, due to be bundled with Wii Sports Resort, offers increased precision and motion mapping; something that punters have argued should have been implemented with the console's release in 2006.
Gameinformer discussed the announcement with a handful of third-party developers, and the general consensus was a feeling of annoyance and betrayal. It seems that studios weren't informed of the change, and it seems that aside from Wii Sports it'll take up to 9 months before third parties would release MotionPlus-enabled titles. Titles already deep in development may suffer looking sluggish and not as precise as newer movement-driven titles.
With third parties in the dark and the need to buy additional hardware to make future games function properly, is the future of MotionPlus already a bleak one?
During E3 the king of console add-ons revealed an advancement for motion control for Wii players: the MotionPlus. The plugin, due to be bundled with Wii Sports Resort, offers increased precision and motion mapping; something that punters have argued should have been implemented with the console's release in 2006.
Gameinformer discussed the announcement with a handful of third-party developers, and the general consensus was a feeling of annoyance and betrayal. It seems that studios weren't informed of the change, and it seems that aside from Wii Sports it'll take up to 9 months before third parties would release MotionPlus-enabled titles. Titles already deep in development may suffer looking sluggish and not as precise as newer movement-driven titles.
With third parties in the dark and the need to buy additional hardware to make future games function properly, is the future of MotionPlus already a bleak one?
Top Stories and Features
Page: 1
Found a shop in my town that only sells Belgian beer and chocolate. :D
4382
L93 Ash Ketchum
Wow, way to go Nintendo.
"Cynical is a word that I apply to the people of the Ford motor company who chose to continue to make the Ford pinto when their gas tanks were exploding because it would be cheaper to pay off the widows than to retool. That's cynicism." - George Carlin
So yeah, Golden Sun 3.
18113
C3 Mod
Let's Tap and Virtua Tennis 2009 hands-on now up!
8960
Reviews Editor
The Conduit doesn't even really need it. A few third parties probably have been told about it - I would reckon Ubisoft are one of those, and this is the reason for the Red Steel 2 delay (as well as general problems with development). I'd also guess SEGA, Capcom and EA are in on it, at least.
Cubed3 Staff :: Reviews Editor
Xbox Live/Twitter :: C3Mike
Cubed3 Staff :: Reviews Editor
Xbox Live/Twitter :: C3Mike
"Make time stand still"
518
L36 Dhalsim
Seems pretty retarted not to tell them. What possible losses could there have been?
"Study this revelation, you nest of adders!"
Resident Evil 5 and Bionic Commando PC Announced
8336
L100 C3 Master
It seems a big shame for titles like the Conduit, I imagine the could have implemented it well. The reload for the energy orb laser would have been great with it.

feeling Fragile.
1696
L65 Tails
Oh, please, 3rd partys for the most part cant manage to scrap gamecube quality games out of the Wii.
They have forfitted any rights to complain about not being at the "cutting edge" of what Nintendo announces.
Besides, it will take a good year before Motion+ is in another hands for it to be worth making a big game for.
3rd partys are really just complaining they didnt have enough warning to bring out some rushed shit and stick the logo on the box.
"It seems a big shame for titles like the Conduit, I imagine the could have implemented it well. The reload for the energy orb laser would have been great with it."
The existing Wiimote is good enough for a reload. (which is a boolean gesture action..if your reloading or not is a yes/no thing).
FPS, likewise, is done ver the IR sensor system...rotational axis is not needed.
Of course, Condiuit could have implimented it...purhapes for, saying, batting stuff back with a gun butt.
But Motionplus is for giving developers the "missing axis", and really, specific games have to be designed from the ground up to use it.
( Edited 23.07.2008 13:53 by Darkflame )Darkflames Favorate Games! - Darkflames Favorate Films! - Darkflames Favorate Foods?!
Dissagree with me?
Make your own reviews at;
www.rateoholic.co.uk : Reviews for anything, by anyone.
They have forfitted any rights to complain about not being at the "cutting edge" of what Nintendo announces.
Besides, it will take a good year before Motion+ is in another hands for it to be worth making a big game for.
3rd partys are really just complaining they didnt have enough warning to bring out some rushed shit and stick the logo on the box.
"It seems a big shame for titles like the Conduit, I imagine the could have implemented it well. The reload for the energy orb laser would have been great with it."
The existing Wiimote is good enough for a reload. (which is a boolean gesture action..if your reloading or not is a yes/no thing).
FPS, likewise, is done ver the IR sensor system...rotational axis is not needed.
Of course, Condiuit could have implimented it...purhapes for, saying, batting stuff back with a gun butt.
But Motionplus is for giving developers the "missing axis", and really, specific games have to be designed from the ground up to use it.
( Edited 23.07.2008 13:53 by Darkflame )
Dissagree with me?
www.rateoholic.co.uk : Reviews for anything, by anyone.
If we were the last man and woman on Earth, I bet we could do it in public
1850
L68 King Boo
SuperLink said:
I knew it. No 1:1 for ages, and probably not in Red Steel 2 like everyone probably wanted, nor in The Conduit. Well done Nintendo. "We luv r 3rd partys!!!1" u shur do.
I knew it. No 1:1 for ages, and probably not in Red Steel 2 like everyone probably wanted, nor in The Conduit. Well done Nintendo. "We luv r 3rd partys!!!1" u shur do.
I think another reason is that Ubisoft saw the conduit and Hight voltage said no to them, so they thought oh fuck, it's going to sell way more than RS2, we actually have to work on it.
Anyway, i'm sure that Nintendo showed it to enough companies(atleast the decent ones) and gave certain companies a big boot to the face by not telling them.
Wasn't the Wii remote a massive shock to alot of the third parties three years ago?

Found a shop in my town that only sells Belgian beer and chocolate. :D
4382
L93 Ash Ketchum
Well, nobody can really say anything about this news as Gameinformer doesn't say which developers they spoke to. It seems logical to me they would contact a few big developers instead of small ones, and then this all seems pretty dumb for Nintendo to do.
"Cynical is a word that I apply to the people of the Ford motor company who chose to continue to make the Ford pinto when their gas tanks were exploding because it would be cheaper to pay off the widows than to retool. That's cynicism." - George Carlin
will be right back after the break.
5803
L100 C3 Master
Sounds like Nintendo are admitting that the motion controls aren't good enough as they are.
As for not telling 3rd parties- it's a great way to piss off gamers and of course the 3rd parties themselves.
This is my newer, bigger, reasonably sized signature. I hope it's not too big.
As for not telling 3rd parties- it's a great way to piss off gamers and of course the 3rd parties themselves.
This is my newer, bigger, reasonably sized signature. I hope it's not too big.
Found a shop in my town that only sells Belgian beer and chocolate. :D
4382
L93 Ash Ketchum
It's a pretty smart business move if you think about how much more money Nintendo can make by releasing a remote and then this thing, instead of releasing the full thing at the start.
Gamers think "Oh imagine how great it would be if you could actually have a proper 1:1 sword fight in Zelda", Nintendo: "We just invented the solution!". Gamers; "Yay! I can't wait to try this."
It's very hard to not get cynical about stuff like this.
Gamers think "Oh imagine how great it would be if you could actually have a proper 1:1 sword fight in Zelda", Nintendo: "We just invented the solution!". Gamers; "Yay! I can't wait to try this."
It's very hard to not get cynical about stuff like this.
"Cynical is a word that I apply to the people of the Ford motor company who chose to continue to make the Ford pinto when their gas tanks were exploding because it would be cheaper to pay off the widows than to retool. That's cynicism." - George Carlin
6918
L100 C3 Master
Nintendo has a history for not making it accommodating for 3rd parties to develop games on their systems. I don't think you'll ever see decent 3rd party support on a Nintendo system, no matter how many systems they have. The ratio of Nintendo games bought to Non-nintendo games will always really favour the former.
186
L19 Rhinobot
If they'd told all of the third parties we'd probably just have a bunch of stupid gimmick games a lot sooner. Seriously, if they were making crap before this came out what's going to make them take things seriously now?
I don't mind seeing some quality come out before everyone else gets their hands on this. That way Nintendo can set the standard. Plus games like The Conduit don't really need it.
I don't mind seeing some quality come out before everyone else gets their hands on this. That way Nintendo can set the standard. Plus games like The Conduit don't really need it.
fine just fine
465
L34 Keese
darkflame pretty much put everything in perspective.
Why You forget Skate It?
2968
L79 Iron Knuckle
Bart.... said:
It's a pretty smart business move if you think about how much more money Nintendo can make by releasing a remote and then this thing, instead of releasing the full thing at the start.
Gamers think "Oh imagine how great it would be if you could actually have a proper 1:1 sword fight in Zelda", Nintendo: "We just invented the solution!". Gamers; "Yay! I can't wait to try this."
It's very hard to not get cynical about stuff like this.
It's a pretty smart business move if you think about how much more money Nintendo can make by releasing a remote and then this thing, instead of releasing the full thing at the start.
Gamers think "Oh imagine how great it would be if you could actually have a proper 1:1 sword fight in Zelda", Nintendo: "We just invented the solution!". Gamers; "Yay! I can't wait to try this."
It's very hard to not get cynical about stuff like this.
They did the exact same with the Balance Board I think. They didn't tell anyone about it, and yet pretty soon titles started coming through including it.
Half the GameInformer article was speculation, speculation of which goes completely against what we've already seen. As long as it's interesting and does enough, then it'll sell. Despite what's been said above, it kinda seems more like Nintendo have usually been pretty accommodating to 3rd parties in spite of surprise announcements.
I really don't see their point on games in deep development. Kinda seems obvious so what would be the point of mentioning it. If after 2 months we've got balance board stuff, I kinda doubt it'd be 6 months minimum for anything to come about.
Nudity, Violence, Strong Language
366
L29 Wolfos
You know what? This is bullsh*t. If anyone has the right to feel annoyed and "betrayed(?)", it's Nintendo and us Wii owners. The sheer amount of sub-GameCube quality games they've been shoveling on Wii is sickening. What GameCube was capable of was very impressive (Rogue Squadron 2 & 3, RE4, MP 1 & 2, SF Adventures, Mario Sunshine, etc.) and considering how much more powerful and efficient Wii is than GC, we should be getting games that are at the very least, twice the quality of the above mentioned GC titles. Consistently. They have absolutely NO right to complain.
I'm really sick of them screwing us over with their low-budget, half-assed, un-inspired, content/feature gimped shite. If Wii was selling poorly, then I can say there's some merit to their lack of effort, but that isn't the case. Not in the slightest. So no. Epic fail.
The Wii Remote works quite well as it is. Any problems with their motion controls is a direct result of poorly thought out and/or implemented motion recognition. Which isn't surprising considering the quality of almost every other aspect of their games is utter crap (i.e. gfx, sfx, Wi-Fi, content, features, etc.).
The Wii Remote works quite well as it is, but it's mainly with medium to large sized movements at preset-like speeds. Better results can be achieved, but like anything else, it requires some actual effort to get. Devs have stated before 1:1 ratio has been achieved and tested, but performance had been rather twitchy (although, that could also be from a lack of proper effort).
Wii MotionPlus, on the other hand, allows games to recognize more subtle and intricate movements at slower speeds allowing for more refined and intuitive gameplay than just the Wii Remote alone. I don't see this as a sign "Nintendo's admitting the Wii Remote fails to deliver" at all.
I find it hard to believe Nintendo wouldn't have clued in 3rd parties without having a good reason. It's possible they only recently reached a point where Wii MotionPlus was at a presentable level and, with E3 imminent, saw they opportunity to showcase their brand new attachment and seized it. Either way, it isn't launching for about year.
I'm really sick of them screwing us over with their low-budget, half-assed, un-inspired, content/feature gimped shite. If Wii was selling poorly, then I can say there's some merit to their lack of effort, but that isn't the case. Not in the slightest. So no. Epic fail.
The Wii Remote works quite well as it is. Any problems with their motion controls is a direct result of poorly thought out and/or implemented motion recognition. Which isn't surprising considering the quality of almost every other aspect of their games is utter crap (i.e. gfx, sfx, Wi-Fi, content, features, etc.).
The Wii Remote works quite well as it is, but it's mainly with medium to large sized movements at preset-like speeds. Better results can be achieved, but like anything else, it requires some actual effort to get. Devs have stated before 1:1 ratio has been achieved and tested, but performance had been rather twitchy (although, that could also be from a lack of proper effort).
Wii MotionPlus, on the other hand, allows games to recognize more subtle and intricate movements at slower speeds allowing for more refined and intuitive gameplay than just the Wii Remote alone. I don't see this as a sign "Nintendo's admitting the Wii Remote fails to deliver" at all.
I find it hard to believe Nintendo wouldn't have clued in 3rd parties without having a good reason. It's possible they only recently reached a point where Wii MotionPlus was at a presentable level and, with E3 imminent, saw they opportunity to showcase their brand new attachment and seized it. Either way, it isn't launching for about year.
If you can read this you are a shisno... A dirty, dirty shisno.
277
L24 Crawlton
So the original Wii-Mote was half-assed?
About to board my plane. Merry Christmas everyone!
3129
L81 Chun-Li
Yet again even more people pissed of at Nintendo.
Honestly Nintendo, good fucking job on your E3 showing.
Honestly Nintendo, good fucking job on your E3 showing.

186
L19 Rhinobot
RATGUOF said:
So the original Wii-Mote was half-assed?
So the original Wii-Mote was half-assed?
Actually it works quite well in the games where developers knew how to use it properly instead of just throwing in random waggle.
tiamat1990 said:
Yet again even more people pissed of at Nintendo.
Honestly Nintendo, good fucking job on your E3 showing.
Yet again even more people pissed of at Nintendo.
Honestly Nintendo, good fucking job on your E3 showing.
I watched ALL of the E3 press conferences and they were ALL snore fests.
E3 just isn't the same anymore.
Add CorruptedJohn on Xbox Live
128
L13 Spore
This is probably an experiment to be properly implemented in the next Generation of console, or Wii2 if you like. This may not take off apart from some Nintendo developed titles (they probably won't force people to buy it) and a few 3rd party releases for a hardcore audience. This will come into its own when it is implemented at launch on another console, and we will get our great games, providing Nintendo hasn't completely sold out by then 



Do ya like ol' gregg's place? Got all things that are good.
743
L44 Ayla
Actually, I agree with MechaG2, if you look at it that way the 3rd party companies (mainly the small ones) DESERVE this, for the shit they put out on our consoles. Only just now I realised that. If they were making dodgy titles pre-E3, that couldn't even match pre-MOTION standards, what makes people think that telling them in advance would improve the quality of their work?
Yes, we might miss out on decent motion+ titles.
Yes, they arn't ALL bad developers.
But i really don't think that Ninty would be so stupid as to not warn ANYONE about this, at least one big-name brand has to know (a chance for R.S 2), and if that's the case then I have no sympathy for the people responsible for $59.99 space-fillers that line the shelves at my local EB games.
Yes, we might miss out on decent motion+ titles.
Yes, they arn't ALL bad developers.
But i really don't think that Ninty would be so stupid as to not warn ANYONE about this, at least one big-name brand has to know (a chance for R.S 2), and if that's the case then I have no sympathy for the people responsible for $59.99 space-fillers that line the shelves at my local EB games.
Can brawl anytime now.....if you want an easy win
BOMBERMAN code: 2879 2176 8600, or just find me in a random match
I think it might be time for Newspapers to look over their sponsorship contracts...
BOMBERMAN code: 2879 2176 8600, or just find me in a random match
I think it might be time for Newspapers to look over their sponsorship contracts...
Subscribe to this topicTo keep up with comments, you can view and add the RSS feed for this topic. (Find out More)
Page: 1

Search C3
Feature Content
3
News Updates

Forums and Blogs
Wi-Fi and Tournaments


Site Feed


Community



WayForward on LIT (Wii)
Nintendo's 'Big Three' on Wii
Nintendo's Post E3 Line-Up Event
RE: Darkside Chronicles - New Video
Final Fantasy Gaiden Revealed for DS
Kingdom Hearts Might Head to Wii
Konami Confirms WiiWare Plans
Punch-Out!!
Doom Resurrection Originally on Wii
Water Warfare, Sudoku, FantasyZone
No More No More Heroes for Wii?
Wii Sports Resort - Huge Ad Campaign
Rumoured Wii Brutal Legend Cancelled
New Dragon Quest IX Japanese Video
Sega Considering Maturing the Wii
Secret of Monkey Island for WiiWare?
Sega Sets a Date for Infinite Space
Next Zelda Not Radically Different
Trackmania Wii Details,Debut Footage
NPC Donkey Kong:Jungle Beat
Chibi-Robo Sweeps up onto DS
Hanabi Kicks off Nintendo Downloads 





