Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

By Adam Riley 30.01.2010 21

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?
Back on 11th March, 2005 in Europe, Nintendo originally unleashed what was meant to be its ‘Third Pillar’ system, the touch-screen enabled DS, which was named as such due to its dual-screen setup (although some deemed it the ‘Developer System’ due to its lower development costs and the simplicity to create games on it). After seeing off the Game Boy Advance and GameCube to become the company’s main platform prior to the release of the Wii, Nintendo capitalised on the new audience that had been drawn to the system thanks to games like nintendogs and Animal Crossing by launching the sleeker DS Lite on 23rd June, 2006, not long after the Western debut of Dr. Kawashima’s Brain Training. Once the preliminary popularity explosion of the platform had begun to settle down somewhat, Nintendo decided another revision was required. As a result, it axed the Game Boy Advance slot, added in a camera and audio playback, as well as introduced an internal web browser and the DSiWare download service for new games for the DSi launch on 3rd April, 2009. A mere eleven months down the line, a larger version, the DSi XL, is due to hit European retail on 5th March, 2010. Cubed3 takes a closer look at what can be expected…

In with the old…

Following on from Cubed3’s illustrative comparison of the Nintendo DSi XL and various other systems and game-related items, now it is time to take a look at what makes it tick. For those that have yet to sample the DSi range, it is important to realise that although the system plays all existing DS releases, there are some features missing from the DS and DS Lite. First of all, the second slot at the bottom of the system has been removed, meaning that it is not backwards compatible with the Game Boy Advance range, nor can games such as Guitar Hero: On Tour be played, since titles such as Activision Blizzard’s music-based product use ‘Slot 2’ for accessories that are fundamental to gameplay. Additionally, whilst standard DS games still have no region restrictions, any titles that have DSi-specific features (using the camera in-game, for instance) or are entirely exclusive to DSi, will indeed be region locked.

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

The new aspects added to the hardware, however, counter-balance these omissions. Given the prominence of the ‘eye’ that appears to be staring at you when the DSi unit is closed, it proves to be a key focal point that will intrigue all new owners. It is in fact one of two cameras included in the system, with the other being an internal one that directly faces the player whilst the system is in use. Both cameras are 0.3 mega-pixels, which produce a standard photo size of 640x480. Clearly the DSi cameras were never intended to become replacements for a standard camera, but for the purposes of playing around with and adding fun extra modes to certain game releases (thanks to the motion detection feature that picks up head and hand movements), they certainly do their job more than adequately.

There is the option to have a photo of your choice act as the desktop background, with it showing whenever the system is booted up and menu navigation is taking place, adding a simple, yet effective, personal touch. In the actual full photo mode there are eleven pre-set effects to play around with, such as merging your face with another person’s, stretching shots, distorting an image into kaleidoscope form or merely adding moustaches and cartoon features before sending the final result to a friend using the local wireless functionality. As pictures are taken, they can be played around with to your heart’s content. Then, when editing has been completed, save them to a chosen album (saved chronologically to store memories and then use the slideshow mode to make the DSi into a digital photo frame), transfer them to an SD card or even upload them directly to Facebook.

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

Furthermore, sound plays a big factor on the DSi. On top of being able to play AAC-encoded music files from an SD card, there is a voice recording element. This allows for small snippets to be recorded, then the pitch and speed tweaked to amusing effect. Want to sound like a trumpet or budgie? No problem! In terms of 'proper' music playback, your favourite tunes can be edited, with equaliser effects such as ‘Radio,’ ‘Instrumental,’ ‘Echo,’ or even the very cool ‘8-Bit,’ which converts songs into an old school NES soundtrack.

The biggest draw has to be the DSiWare service, though, where DSi owners can download brand new titles and applications from the Nintendo DSi Shop directly to the 512MB of internal space on the hardware, copying content across to an SD card when necessary. Betweeen the initial line-up of Paper Plane (Paper Airplane), Pyoro (Bird & Beans), WarioWare: Snapped!, Art Style: AQUITE (AQUIA), Art Style: CODE (DECODE), and other high quality releases since the service commenced, such as Reflect Missile, 2-in-1 Solitaire, and Art Style: INTERSECT (DIGIDRIVE), it brings a whole new world of gaming into the palm of your hand. As an added bonus, your DSiWare account can be linked with your official Nintendo one so Stars can be accrued for every download, which can then in turn be converted into more Nintendo Points for the payment of future downloads.

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

...and in with the new!

Although Nintendo has stated that it believes the DSi XL is a ‘kinder, gentler DS’ as opposed to merely being a larger version of the hardware purely aimed at an older demographic, clearly the increased screen size and extra large pen included will appeal to those that found the screens on earlier DS units to be too small and the stylus too fiddly. Whilst the DSi screens jumped 17% in size to 3.25-inches when being upgraded from the DS Lite model, a much larger increase has been employed this time round, with the DSi XL coming with two 4.2-inch screens. Originally set to be a DS Lite XL a couple of years ago with 3.8-inch screens, units sales of the hardware were so high at the time that it made no sense to water down the manufacturing process. Putting the project on hold was certainly a wise decision, with the wait definitely being worth it as the cost of manufacture had significantly reduced after a couple of years had passed, meaning not only could 4.2-inch screens be used, but wide-angle viewing LCD screens that allow clear vision even from a side vantage point.

Other than the cheaper cost factor, one of the primary ideas behind making the decision to go slightly larger and make the LCD screens wide-angled was that many people like to see what is going on when someone else is playing, so previously people have had to crowd around a DS and forcibly move closer to the system to see the action. However, now the system can easily be viewed by two people, first of all due to the new screen type, and secondly as the system's top screen can be placed at different opening angles thanks to its two hinge positions. Rather than just the 155 degree angle of the DS, now there is a 120 degree option available. This second position was included so that the machine could easily be left open on a table-top, encouraging other members of the family to simply jump straight in and play once someone has finished with the system, or so that anyone sat down playing a game could easily be watched, making it simpler to receive a helping hand in the Professor Layton series of games, as well as others of its ilk.

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

Other aesthetic changes of note include a slightly larger power button and easier to adjust volume tabs. Even the standard stylus is marginally longer than previous designs. For those that still have trouble with the thin stylus, there is an extra choice of using the thick pen-like version included in the box. This pen is made of three components moulded together, and the key factor is that one of these pieces protrudes like the clip on a pen. This is no accident, with it being done so upon finishing a gaming session, leaving the DSi XL behind on a tabletop, the pen can be left on the same flat surface without it rolling away and potentially becoming lost down the back of a radiator or gap in the floor-boards. The extra size of the DSi XL may be seen to be a disadvantage by some, since it means that more weight has been added. However, it is actually only 100-grammes heavier than a DSi, with the change in weight feeling negligible when held, even for long periods of time. The shape has been altered as well, with it no longer being a uniform cuboid. Nintendo has styled it in the form of an inverted trapezium, done so in order to make opening the lid less awkward.

On the sound front, Nintendo was hoping to increase the volume of the hardware in general, yet due to all the internal components remaining the same, upping the level on the current speakers would have distorted the sound too much. However, a solution came in the form of changing the speaker holes from the two small horizontal ones of the DSi to two sets of seven tiny holes set in a circular pattern of six, with the final hole located right in the centre. This has resulted in a clearer audio experience overall, and the reality that everything sounds a little louder than before despite being the actual same speaker as in the DSi model.


As for the colours Nintendo has chosen to release the DSi XL in, for the Japanese launch there was Dark Brown, Wine Red and Natural White. Initially the Wine Red choice was not going to be made available, but the disparity between the white and brown made the two models clash when promoted side-by-side. Introducing a third colour alleviated such problems for the marketing team and has in fact now proven to be the most popular selection, not only amongst the older demographic, but younger women as well, a sector Nintendo presumed would opt for the Natural White model instead.

Whether Nintendo sticks with these three launch colours is yet another aspect that remains unconfirmed at the time of writing for the US market, but no doubt plenty of behind-the-scenes market research is being conducted to come to a final conclusion. Europe is set to get the Dark Brown and Wine Red models. These colours are not just plain either, as with older models. Taking the Wine Red model that Nintendo sent out to Cubed3, there are four thin layers of two-tone plastic with coloured ink printed on to create a polished top panel, rather than merely one flimsy, cheap-looking cover like the protective cases being sold by Third Parties accessory producers right now that clip onto the system. The DS Lite and DSi models were meant to have had two-tone colour selections, but their complicated hinges meant the desired outcome could not be reached without the end result looking less than professional in Nintendo's eyes. The shiny top panel is not just flat either, with it swelling slightly, being designed to mimic the surface tension of water in a bowl, giving not only a gentle feel, but a smart finish as well, and adds a touch more protection to the external camera eye.

Image for Feature | How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

Image courtesy of Kotaku


Once the DSi XL has been booted up, the menu layout is the same, with all pieces of software and applications represented by boxes lined-up in a horizontal row, with either the stylus or D-pad allowing for scrolling along. Whilst highlighting a particular box, tapping Up on the D-pad pulls it out of the line, ready for movement to a preferred position. However, there is a subtle change coming in the form of the actual content. The menu start-up has been altered to include a few extra features, free of charge. Flipnote Studio, the Opera Internet Browser, A Little Bit of...Brain Training: Maths Edition and A Little Bit of...Brain Training: Arts Edition are all present and correct now, with the Japanese version also having an English dictionary included. Apparently it is undecided whether or not the US system will include a similar line-up, but in Europe the 6-in-1 Dictionary DSiWare product will indeed be pre-installed along with the other applications and games listed (apart from the maths edition of Brain Training). Flipnote and the browser were obviously included because they are free downloads anyway, so it makes sense to remove the extra hassle for new buyers. As for the Brain Training titles, these were included because Iwata-san believed many fans of the retail releases may not have known how to download games, despite the DSiWare service being quite user-friendly.

Finally, along with the chunky pen-like stylus, the Japanese edition comes with a voucher in the box that entitles owners to receive a free version of the Nero Music2Go software that allows the user to easily convert audio files from music CDs or songs stored on a PC into the AAC format the DSi recognises and transfer said files onto an SD card for portable playback. It also allows direct management of files on an SD card, plus provides access to detailed song, artist and album information for audio CDs. This software is normally GBP4.99, so it is a nice little extra inclusion to encourage people to make use of the audio features of the system. Again this is a Japanese-only feature until confirmed otherwise, yet hopefully it will be included in the West. It has also not been confirmed if the 1,000 free Nintendo Points will be offered when starting up the DSiWare service for the very first time. The Japanese DSi LL does have this welcomed addition, so hopefully Nintendo will keep the offer open so other territories do not miss out. After all, the more incentives for purchasing the DSi XL, the better in the consumer’s eye.

The Nintendo DSi XL is a fantastic piece of kit, offering all the technological advances of a DSi unit, whilst successfully upgrading the entire playing experience and adding a pleasing variety of extras to sweeten the deal. Although it may not be an essential purchase for current DSi owners, anyone who has so far wavered, sticking with the DS and DS Lite models should definitely give this some strong consideration.
Box art for Nintendo DSi XL (LL)
Developer

Nintendo

Publisher

Nintendo

Genre

Other

Players

1

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  n/a

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  1/10 (1 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Comment on this article

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Comments

I think it was simply the matter of people going up to Nintendo and saying "I really want to use the DS but it is too small for me to hold or see the screen" and Nintendo saying "ok, we'll see what we can do about that". I have the DSi and I love it, but I doubt that the DSi XL would be more suitable for anyone on this website.

Very nice article, Adam! Smilie

But, I could be spending my money on something else instead of just a rehash of the same old, same old. Wait a minute, I'm a Nintendo fan. Never mind... Smilie

However, it is actually only 100-grammes heavier than a DSi

Oh you Europeans and your silly spellings! Smilie


The former top user was Keven! You'd probably give birth to yourself 1000 times over until you sprout wings to fly away into the fading sun, that or you'd just turn into a lesbian. Who knows @_@ - L, 12/06/09

I have the DSi and I love it, but I doubt that the DSi XL would be more suitable for anyone on this website.

My feeling too.

I do think one actual weakpoint of the DS's design is the volume adjustment though. They say they have improved that too.
A wheel would have been best though, like the GBA.

http://www.fanficmaker.com <-- Tells some truly terrible tales.
Last update; Mice,Plumbers,Animatronics and Airbenders. We also have the socials; Facebook & G+

The one thing I didn't touch upon was price, since I've not been given any indication as to what it will sell at. However, just taking a look at Amazon UK now, it seems that the RRP is GBP159.99, but retailers are willing to knock it down by a tenner, which puts it in-line with the DSi price, I believe.

Darkflame said:
I do think one actual weakpoint of the DS's design is the volume adjustment though. They say they have improved that too. A wheel would have been best though, like the GBA.

The volume buttons look the same, but are much easier to tap now. The DSi versions need to be firmly pressed to get them to click, whereas the XL model's ones are much easier to tap on.

Another little point - watching the little Mario character run back and forth when downloading stuff from the DSiWare service on both systems at the same time gives a very good idea of the difference in image size. Think I'll definitely be sticking with the XL from now on - the bigger screen is fantastic! Shame I can't transfer all my current DSiWare games across to it Smilie

Adam Riley [ Director :: Cubed3 ]

UNITE714: Weekly Prayers | Bible Verses

Q: How Essential is the Nintendo DSi XL?

A: Not essential at all, you don't need it to survive.

It's the same as the others. Don't need.

Hmm? What's that? No GBA slot? Still not interested. Smilie

Seriously, a bigger DSi with a bigger stylus, some mature colors, and a little more pre-installed? Even if I had a DSi, this still wouldn't look any more arousing.

( Edited 31.01.2010 23:18 by PK, Mongoose Hermit )

It requires great courage to look at oneself honestly, and forge one's own path.


I wouldn't recommend this for those that have already bought a DSi, but anyone that's been toying with the idea of picking one up should definitely look at getting this model instead.

I barely ever used the GBA slot, and since there are so many great games on DSiWare, with heaps more on the horizon, I would have happily paid to upgrade from the DS Lite to a DSi. This XL version makes the prospect of buying a DSi even more tempting.

Considering it won't be priced much more than a standard DSi, it makes more sense to get this one.

Adam Riley [ Director :: Cubed3 ]

UNITE714: Weekly Prayers | Bible Verses

Every time my friends play a DSP after playing their DSis, they comment on how smooth the sprites of 2D games look in comparison.

Also I've come to realise recently that I really appreciate the GBA slot. GBA games look really nice on the DS (backlight) and the sound is great too.

So yeah, if my DSP ever breaks, I'm pretty sure I'm getting another DSP somehow.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Toon SuperLink said:
Every time my friends play a DSP after playing their DSis, they comment on how smooth the sprites of 2D games look in comparison.

Really, you still use your original DS?! The only time that gets an airing now is if I'm playing on my DSL and my wife wants to play Tetris, so I give her the old machine!

Also I've come to realise recently that I really appreciate the GBA slot. GBA games look really nice on the DS (backlight) and the sound is great too. So yeah, if my DSP ever breaks, I'm pretty sure I'm getting another DSP somehow.

Guess that is a -1 for considering a DSi or DSi XL then Smilie

Adam Riley [ Director :: Cubed3 ]

UNITE714: Weekly Prayers | Bible Verses

jesusraz said:
I wouldn't recommend this for those that have already bought a DSi, but anyone that's been toying with the idea of picking one up should definitely look at getting this model instead.

I barely ever used the GBA slot, and since there are so many great games on DSiWare, with heaps more on the horizon, I would have happily paid to upgrade from the DS Lite to a DSi. This XL version makes the prospect of buying a DSi even more tempting.

Considering it won't be priced much more than a standard DSi, it makes more sense to get this one.

But then again, Nintendo have done as many revisions for the DS line as they did for the Game Boy line, but have done so in half the time. Then there's all the talk/rumours of the successor. It's possibly a bad time to buy a DS, with yet another inevitable upgrade just around the corner.

Toon SuperLink said:
Every time my friends play a DSP after playing their DSis, they comment on how smooth the sprites of 2D games look in comparison.

What's a DSP?

( Edited 02.02.2010 23:23 by Martin_ )

Martin_ said:
What's a DSP?

DS Phat.
The good ol' ugly DS.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Why don't you just say 'DS', then? That's its official handle.

· DS
The original.

· DSL
The DS Lite.

· DSi
You guessed it..

· DSi XL
The newest one.

Why complicate matters even further with your own special acronyms? Smilie

Martin_ said:
Why don't you just say 'DS', then? That's its official handle.

Because DS is also a general term for the whole series of consoles. By saying DSP people know exactly what you're talking about.

Even Cammie Friggin Dunaway says DSP.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

I would get a DSP over a DSi anyday. There are features on that that I can't use on anything else I have. If I want to listen to music I will use my Ipod. I can use a camera for pictures. Plus there is no GBA slot, which is annoying for anyone that does not have a GBA. I have a DSi but I would gladly get a DSP because the Dpad feels really uncomfortable plus irratating to use sometimes.



SuperYoshi6 PSN name
3DS friend code 2878-9581-8999

Toon SuperLink said:
Because DS is also a general term for the whole series of consoles. By saying DSP people know exactly what you're talking about.

Even Cammie Friggin Dunaway says DSP.

Fair point, just never heard the term myself and was confused.

Dark Magician Girl said:
I have a DSi but I would gladly get a DSP because the Dpad feels really uncomfortable plus irratating to use sometimes.

Hmm, that's interesting. Must be personal preference, since I wasn't a massive fan of the original DS system's D-pad, yet the one on the DSi is just fine and dandy!

Adam Riley [ Director :: Cubed3 ]

UNITE714: Weekly Prayers | Bible Verses

PMD said:
I have the DSi and I love it, but I doubt that the DSi XL would be more suitable for anyone on this website.


Your right, the dsi was built for the children,while the dsi xl is for adults or teens...�_�

battle it out with me??? its NOT like you'll win,HAHAHA :p
Craig (guest) 14.02.2010#19

SmilieSounds awsome, cant wait.

selena (guest) 05.06.2010#20

it rock littel big but i like it
your text hereSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilie

manon (guest) 20.06.2010#21

jadore la nintendo dsi xl SmilieSmilie et jaimerai bien lavoir a mon anniv !!

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
Azuardo, Insanoflex, Ofisil

There are 3 members online at the moment.