Pokémon Was Supposed to End With Gold/Silver

By Stuart Lawrence 12.03.2010 21

Pokémon Was Supposed to End With Gold/Silver on Nintendo gaming news, videos and discussion

With Pokémon HeartGold/SoulSilver just round the corner, and a fifth generation supposedly coming out this year, most people would think that the series was meant to go on forever. But according to the President of the Pokémon Company; Tsunekazu Ishihara it was all supposed to end with the second generation.

In the latest Iwata Asks he says:

I worked with the assumption that after we put out Gold and Silver, my work as far as Pokémon was concerned would be done, I didn't intend to make any more Pokémon titles. I even thought that once we entered the twenty-first century, it would be time for me to do something else entirely.

I remember that when Gold and Silver were released, I felt like a burden had finally been lifted from my shoulders. We'd had our sights set on the finish line of Gold and Silver for so long, and now that we'd finally completed the major series running right through from Red and Blue, I felt I could say to Tajiri-san: "I've fulfilled my duty!"

Once we'd released Gold and Silver and it was selling even faster than Red and Green, I couldn't very well get off the ride halfway through saying: "Nice work everyone. Good luck from here on in!"

-Tsunekazu Ishihara

Thanks to Official Nintendo Magazine.

What do you think of the significance of the decision to carry on with the Pokémon series? Would you have been disappointed if it stopped at Gold/Silver?

Box art for Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver
Developer

Game Freak

Publisher

Nintendo

Genre

Turn Based RPG

Players

5

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  9/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  7/10 (32 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Comment on this article

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Comments

Would you have been dissapointed if it stopped at Gold/Silver?

I would probably be that much closer to considering cancelling my irl subscription.

Seriously, I can't believe it was meant to be that short. Smilie Thank god they kept it going. Pokémon is easily my favourite game series, it's hard to imagine my gaming life without it ^^;

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Well the games haven't changed drastically since, so maybe in actual fact they did stop at G/S.

Add me on anything. I'm always looking for new friends/opponents/town visitors/chances to appear more popular than I actually am.

Maybe that's why there was so much effort put into the Gold/Silver games while the newer games seem kinda lazy (they are still great games, DPP being my favorite generation).

I doubt that Nintendo planned on stopping pokemon after the second generation- they probably figured they would move development to a different team.

Edracon (guest) 13.03.2010#4

I wish it did end back then. All the pokemon games after those two (except for cristal) sucked. Platinum was ok.

My gaming experience is based upon Pokemon and all that it is. It's what brought me into gaming, it's what brought me to Nintendo and it's what brought me to where I'm at in life. That sounds way big, but I'm known for being a Pokemon kid. (And not the kind that is socially incapable. It's a positive thing for people with me.)
In short, I'm glad they kept going.
The significance amounts to each individual person. In terms of the gaming industry, it made something that can't be replicated and liked as much. Pokemon stands out on its own accord. (Of course, I speak only of the main series and its main console counterparts; Pokemon Colosseum for Pokemon Ruby, Sapphire and Emerald for example.)

I admit that the pokemon after the second generation started to look totally weird. But to think that it would've ended with Gold/Silver is a scary thought. Not only does pokemon keep getting more fans, it sticks with the older ones aswell. I can't imagine how it would've been without more pokemon. Smilie
Even when I fell out of gaming I still got bursts of "pokemania".

New games aswell as remakes of old, they always pull through. Sure, if the series goes on for too long it might get silly, but not yet!

Still waiting/hoping for a mmorpg. *cough* I believe that would maybe even beat World of Warcraft in popularity. Smilie

I'm so glad that Pokemon is still popular.

What I don't understand is why they wont release a new main-stream Pokemon title on the Wii. It would sell crazy like Mario Kart or NSMB Wii.

"Do a Barrel Roll!"

I think G/S had the most effort - loads of Gyms, good sidequests - the whole lot really. I can see why they thought it would end there and they wanted to conclude with a bang. D/P I liked, but it was far too short imo - found it hard to pace out!

Cubed3 Admin/Founder & Designer

If this was the case I would lose the will to live. Because the Pokemon games are awesome. They should not have been saying that these could have been the last in the series. Stupid Nintendo, why end a perfectly strong game series?



SuperYoshi6 PSN name
3DS friend code 2878-9581-8999

Looking back, pokemon Gold/Silver are FAR superior to the pokemon games that followed. I almost wish it had all ended with the 2nd generation, but I still hold out hope of Nintendo making a great pokemon game again.

I've recently started playing Gold again and it made me realise that the love for the 2nd gen had nothing to do nostalgia and everything to do with them being totally amazing.

Cheesing it up said:
Looking back, pokemon Gold/Silver are FAR superior to the pokemon games that followed.

I'm not seeing it, I can't stand the old box system and how slow you travel/etc. The upgrades made since Gen 2 have been pretty major really. They may not be across 2 regions, but both Johto and Kanto are incredibly tiny in comparison to Hoenn and Sinnoh.

I've recently started playing Gold again and it made me realise that the love for the 2nd gen had nothing to do nostalgia and everything to do with them being totally amazing.

Unless you're talking about the remakes I think they've aged pretty badly. It all feels dated, the game mechanics are broken/unfair and everything is much slower paced.

Top that off with how annoying rematches are to hold in Gen II, and no Safari Zone, and there are plenty of things Gen II lacks.

( Edited 22.03.2010 17:00 by SuperLink )

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

I can't stand the old box system and how slow you travel/etc. The upgrades made since Gen 2 have been pretty major really. They may not be across 2 regions, but both Johto and Kanto are incredibly tiny in comparison to Hoenn and Sinnoh.

Alright, the box system was hardly genius (although I can't even remember how it's done on Diamond). The upgrades have been major? I disagree. The only things I've noticed so far is the addition of things like telling you how much your stats have changed when you level up, or telling you how many of an item you already have when buying from a shop.

They may not be across 2 regions, but both Johto and Kanto are incredibly tiny in comparison to Hoenn and Sinnoh.

Again I disagree. They're all a pretty decent size, but you can't beat the idea of 16 gym leaders!

Unless you're talking about the remakes I think they've aged pretty badly. It all feels dated, the game mechanics are broken/unfair and everything is much slower paced.

No, I'm not talking about the remakes (I don't even understand why people would buy pokemon remakes tbh). The game still feels as fresh as ever to me. I don't really know what's broken about it either although i admit there may be something I'm not seeing. As for slower paced, ARE YOU HAVING A LAUGH!? Diamond is a crawl compared to Gold/Silver! I get frustrated by how slow the battles are in Diamond compared to Gold, along with how long it takes just to save your progress.

Top that off with how annoying rematches are to hold in Gen II, and no Safari Zone, and there are plenty of things Gen II lacks.

I don't bother with rematches, although I admit the addition of a Safari Zone style location would have been nice.

Also Pokegear>>Pokewatch

Cheesing it up said:

Alright, the box system was hardly genius (although I can't even remember how it's done on Diamond). The upgrades have been major? I disagree.

Check out the box system in HG/SS and say that again.

The only things I've noticed so far is the addition of things like telling you how much your stats have changed when you level up, or telling you how many of an item you already have when buying from a shop.

Those thing are pretty minor imo, I'm surprised you even noticed them.

Again I disagree. They're all a pretty decent size, but you can't beat the idea of 16 gym leaders!

In Gen 2 you can beat Chuck and Jasmine within minutes of each other, and you can pretty much conquer Kanto in a day. That's amazing pacing, right there./sarcasm

The game still feels as fresh as ever to me. I don't really know what's broken about it either although i admit there may be something I'm not seeing.

Psychic types can destroy most Pokémon with ease, in Gen II there were still no good Bug/Dark Moves/Pokémon.

As for slower paced, ARE YOU HAVING A LAUGH!? Diamond is a crawl compared to Gold/Silver! I get frustrated by how slow the battles are in Diamond compared to Gold, along with how long it takes just to save your progress.

No I'm not, yes D/P were slow in battles but Platinum was fine and HG/SS are arguably even faster in battles than the oldest titles. That's not even what I was getting at. Enjoy walking for the whole game and riding a bike that barely goes faster than Gen 3/4's running speed.

The saving progress thing is just ridiculous though, and it's the developers' fault, it could very easily be made quicker.

I don't bother with rematches

Probably because Gen 2 is your favourite and they're pretty much useless in that. In Gen 3/4 they're incredibly handy for training.

Also Pokegear>>Pokewatch

Disagree completely, having to open a menu every time you want to look at the map is incredibly annoying after playing D/P/Pt.
Although I do love the radio and the phone, I wish Gen 4 had that. Even Gen 3 had a phone.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Check out the box system in HG/SS and say that again.

I will check them out at some point.

you can pretty much conquer Kanto in a day. That's amazing pacing, right there./sarcasm

I admit the Kanto region is comparatively short, but it's like a bonus more then anything else. I have no complaints.

Psychic types can destroy most Pokémon with ease, in Gen II there were still no good Bug/Dark Moves/Pokémon.

The dark type was added specifically to weaken Psychic pokemon, so it's clearly less broken then the 1st generation. And correct me if I'm wrong but isn't Ghost also Super effective against Psychic? Shadow ball is a pretty good move.

Enjoy walking for the whole game and riding a bike that barely goes faster than Gen 3/4's running speed

I have missed the ability to run, generally it's fine. Any significant travelling is done by bike (once you get one), which goes plenty fast for me.

Cheesing it up said:

I admit the Kanto region is comparatively short, but it's like a bonus more then anything else. I have no complaints.

Thing is without Kanto, Gen 2 is even shorter/easier than Gen 1 ^-^;

The dark type was added specifically to weaken Psychic pokemon, so it's clearly less broken then the 1st generation.

Yeah that's for sure, but it's still consierably more broken than later gens.

And correct me if I'm wrong but isn't Ghost also Super effective against Psychic? Shadow ball is a pretty good move.

Most ghost types in Gen II are part Poison which Psychic can obliterate with ease, even if they do happen to have a strong Ghost move on their arsenal. Misdreavous isn't Poison, but you can only get it right at the end of the game, and its stats aren't brilliant either.

I have missed the ability to run, generally it's fine. Any significant travelling is done by bike (once you get one), which goes plenty fast for me.

Yeah the bike is fine, but that's still quite a ways into the game and can't be used indoors or in building dungeons.

EDIT: Oh man, playing HG/SS reminds me how ridiculous the pacing was in this gen. Grinding to fight stronger enemies was a joke because the Wild Pokémon were so weak and rematches are awkward, and 3 or more Gym Leaders had Pokémon levelled between 20 and 30.

And then there's a huge difficulty jump after you get to Kanto. I'd have thought they'd have fixed the levelling problems for the remakes Smilie

( Edited 24.03.2010 18:16 by SuperLink )

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Thing is without Kanto, Gen 2 is even shorter/easier than Gen 1 ^-^

Yeh, it is probably the easiest pokemon out there, but it's still a good length before Kanto is added, and Kanto does add a significant amount (sure it's short for a whole region, but it's still several hours of gameplay).

Also, the ease of completing the game is somewhat made up for by the tear-your-hair-out legendary dogs.

Yeah that's for sure, but it's still consierably more broken than later gens.

I wouldn't really call it broken. Sure, psychic is one of the better types, but it's not like it completely owns everything. I'm sure I remember a good bug move as well, but I may be mistaken.

Yeah the bike is fine, but that's still quite a ways into the game and can't be used indoors or in building dungeons.

It's not really that far in the game tbh, but I agree that being able to run would be nice.

( Edited 25.03.2010 21:50 by Cheesing it up )

Cheesing it up said:

I wouldn't really call it broken. Sure, psychic is one of the better types, but it's not like it completely owns everything. I'm sure I remember a good bug move as well, but I may be mistaken.

Megahorn iirc.
But even then there are no powerful Bug types to use it. Heracross is OK, but it's also part Fighting, let one decent Psychic type attack before it and bam, it's done.

And I haven't played Gen2 for a while, but man, I don't remember it being this ridiculously easy o.0;, Clair's team is made up of Pokémon mostly under 40, and not a single Gym Leader after Bugsy was very challenging at all.

This post from someone another forum puts it quite well:


Considering the lofty heights the levels get to in this Gen, how are you supposed to train when Pokémon in the wild just barely break 40 by Mt Silver?
I wish they'd added a more Vs Seeker like option to the Pokégear. The phone is awesome, but it sucks for rematches.

If it weren't for the awesome features in HG/SS (amazing detail in everything, Poké followers, and amazing touch control), I'd say Gen IV would be the best, almost without doubt Smilie

( Edited 25.03.2010 22:09 by SuperLink )

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery
GoldEars (guest) 11.01.2011#18

To be quite honest, if it didend, then there would be no Mystery Dungeon.

used cars salerod newcar


( Edited 18.01.2011 08:55 by bantankhoon )



Pichi (guest) 05.09.2011#20

The question is, why didn't it end?
Not like I wanted it to end, but...

Mgapope (guest) 30.05.2016#21

Well, if it would've ended after gold and silver, I wouldn't know about it, so it's a good thing they kept it around.

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
Azuardo

There are 1 members online at the moment.