Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D (PC) Review

By Aria DiMezzo 15.05.2016

Review for Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D on PC

Star Wars: Rogue Squadron was one of those games that didn't go down in history as one of the best, yet probably deserved to. It is to aerial dogfight games as Diddy Kong Racing is to the kart racer. Although this rerelease is being touted by some as a port of the N64 game (which is unlikely to ever get a Virtual Console release), it's actually the original PC version, and nothing has been changed except that it now functions on modern systems. Is that enough to entice gamers to once again fell AT-ATs on Hoth? Cubed3 prepares to shoot first.

Those more familiar with the console release will find much to love about the PC game, as everything is noticeably improved from the N64, but, without a number of homebrew hacks, there is no quantifiable improvement from the 90s PC version itself. Since there already exists a myriad of ways to replay the previously-purchased 1998 release on contemporary systems, Factor 5 failed to provide incentive for buying anew: there are no achievements, trading cards, or any of the other benefits we've come to expect.

Reports of joystick and control problems mar the official Steam forum, which is rather disturbing given that the studio has had nearly two decades to work out bugs, and an almost crippling issue with the camera plagues nearly everyone. This is resolved by pressing the POV key, but the glitch occurs with surprising regularity; since the bug causes immediate disorientation, it is the cause of many frustrating crashes into mountains, but no fix appears to be in the works for this problem that, by all rights, should have been resolved by now, anyway. It wouldn't be a late 90s game, though, if the camera didn't hover between "functional" and "utterly broken."

There is still so much to love about Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D, especially since it is such a rare breed; the copies of the more popular N64 game circulating the Internet are little more than a tantalising dessert that is forever out of reach. If Wedge is to once more be rescued from the prison on Kessel, as Han would say, this is the only ship that can make it happen in under twelve parsecs.

Screenshot for Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D on PC

Across nineteen missions (which add up to more play time than might be expected), each of which must first be beaten with a specific ship before more options are available for that particular stage, players take control of Luke Skywalker between A New Hope and The Empire Strikes Back. Fighting alongside other pilots like Biggs and Wedge to accomplish Goldeneye 007-like objectives along the way, Luke often must protect shuttles, destroy shield generators, engage in dogfights with TIE Interceptors, and blow up everything else that is represented on the map by a red square.

Each of the ships handle differently and have wildly different abilities, and clever game design allows nearly any ship to complete any mission. Bronze, Silver, and Gold medals are earned for completing stages quickly, killing many enemies, finding bonuses, and saving allies, adding another reason to replay stages to the point of mastering them. Although the Naboo Starfighter indisputably reigns supreme, balance is tuned so finely that even this golden beast never guarantees a matching medal; the only way to succeed is to practice.

Three of the missions are bonus stages, of course, and comprise some of the best levels in the game: the classic Death Star trench run, the Battle of Hoth, and a shuttle race through the canyons of Tatooine. The latter may sound lame compared to the epic glories awaiting the hero who navigates the narrow canals of the Empire's deadliest weapon while dodging laser blasts from a seemingly infinite supply of TIE Fighters, but it's no less satisfying and every bit as entertaining. With the difficulty of earning some of the medals, however, simply unlocking these stages is cause for celebration, and handily beating them with Bronze and Silver medals is easy and sometimes trite compared to the effort it takes simply to earn the right to play them.

Missteps do impede the experience, and that Mark Hamill didn't provide the voice of Luke Skywalker may be jarring to hardcore fans, but with the low quality of the voice recordings it's hard to judge how authentic the voice actor is. Everything feels like Star Wars, though, and that counts for a lot; the music provides the right atmosphere, the sound effects are fitting, and the graphics… hold up decently enough. An expert difficulty curve accompanies excellent game design, allowing almost anyone to complete the game while still offering plenty of challenge via its medals, although some of the missions feel like they're hardly more than a human stress test.

Screenshot for Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D on PC

Cubed3 Rating

7/10
Rated 7 out of 10

Very Good - Bronze Award

Rated 7 out of 10

Like a kart racer of the same era, Star Wars: Rogue Squadron 3D left quite a strong impression on those who played it, and there hasn't been much like it since. The graphics and sound quality don't hold up today as well as they did twenty years ago, but that's okay—the original film trilogy's audio and video aren't quite as great in modern times, either. The few problems that really plague the game aren't enough to make it unplayable, but revisiting this classic is more than just a nostalgia trip; it brings the frustration and rage of semi-broken 90s cameras right back to the surface. It's fun, and it's still great, but there's no excuse for these problems to persist today.

Developer

Factor 5

Publisher

LucasArts

Genre

Shooter

Players

1

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  7/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  0 (0 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date None   Australian release date Out now   

Comments

Comments are currently disabled

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
Insanoflex, jesusraz, Ofisil

There are 3 members online at the moment.