FIFA 18 (Nintendo Switch) Review

By Tomas Barry 02.10.2017 5

Review for FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch

Excluding the legacy editions of FIFA 14 and 15 on the original Wii, it's not since the rather neglected FIFA 13 on the Wii U that EA has released a mainline FIFA on a current Nintendo home console. That edition was quite poorly received, largely because it was clear that version wasn't being given the attention it required. While fans could accept an out-of-date engine, it was the absence of major modes such as Ultimate Team, as well as the fact that it was a carbon copy of FIFA 12 in technical terms, that signalled a less than ideal arrangement. Fast-forward to the present, and there are some parallels for FIFA 18; namely, how do you provide an up-to-date experience on lesser-powered hardware? And how does one suitably accommodate Nintendo's eccentricities? In this case, the feasibility of tiny individual Joy-Con for two-player matches, and, of course, the less-than-ideal online environment.

Since football is football, let's jump right into what clicks about FIFA 18 on the Switch and what doesn't. On the pitch, it performs rather well, as long as we temper our expectations. The Switch version runs on a custom engine, apparently derived from the FIFA 16 Ignite engine, which provides a fluid and lively experience that, at a glance, could be mistaken for the more powerful versions based on the Frostbite engine.

It's not a million miles away from a visual point of view, with very crisp and vibrant visuals, and no signs of slowdown or strain. You can't scrutinize every blade of grass in the same way, and players do lack the cutting-edge animations that avid FIFA fans will be accustomed to on other systems, but there's no doubt that this still makes the grade. That's especially true considering this is a portable version of FIFA. When playing in handheld mode, FIFA 18 looks rather brilliant, even if the screen size does lead to some uncomfortable squinting, which isn't exactly alleviated by bringing the screen closer in.

Screenshot for FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch

In handheld mode, it's also a slight struggle to be precise, since the Joy-Con controllers are so small. The shoulder button arrangement feels far too cramped for those accustomed to bigger pads, as it doesn't have the real estate of a PS4 or Xbox controller. This results in difficulty when trying to combine shoulder button inputs, which, personally, lead to a more diluted style of play simply to avoid the physical pain. This is probably the sort of compromise that most will accept, given that the only real handheld alternative is a dire mobile device version, but it's a shame that even a configuration switch can't solve this lack of precision control when playing with that handheld control scheme.

The less said about the single Joy-Con experience, the better. Good luck with that. Unless you're seven years old, it's unlikely to be bearable for longer than a few minutes, even with the simple controls. The biggest issue of both handheld controls and single Joy-Con is that the analogue stick itself is too small, and all too often, due to its smaller range, lofted through-balls get cannoned off wildly in the wrong direction. It's possible to improve, but it's far from ideal, as the best through-ball often feels off-limits because of this struggle for grip and angle precision.

Screenshot for FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch

Thankfully, in docked mode, playing with a Pro Controller, FIFA 18 is a great experience. The extra details (observable when blown up to 1080p in docked mode) really do shine, giving it a crispness that elevates it visually beyond the Xbox 360 and PS3 editions by some margin. Despite the custom engine, which really is being used as a stepping stone before a fully-fledged Frostbite version is implemented, the quality on the pitch, both visually and from a gameplay point of view, feels surprisingly in touch with its big brother, without quite offering the same technical range for ball control delivered in more powerful editions.

Disappointingly, though, despite this achievement on the pitch, there are other departments of FIFA 18 that come up a little short. Some of these are in the name of transition, which seems acceptable, but others seem like more complicated issues.

Relating to the former, the Career mode of FIFA 18 on Switch is not even the same as FIFA 17's; rather, it's based on the year prior to that, which seems a little lazy. Elsewhere, on the Ultimate Team front, while it's here in fundamental form, it lacks the new Squad Challenges, Daily Challenges, and the FUT Champions mode, which can be found in other versions. In other words, everything being introduced to the Switch version of FIFA 18 is derived from old code.

Screenshot for FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch

Although there are plenty of nice aesthetic enhancements to give it a leg-up on legacy editions, anyone who has played the series on and off in the last half-decade will know where the corners have been cut. There are more significant missing features, such as the returning story mode seen on PC, PS4 and Xbox One, which means that even with the specific unique additions, such as the local seasons mode, fans with high expectations will end up feeling a little short-changed. Let's not forget that this edition costs the same as the others.

There's also a lack of flexibility within Ultimate Team. Despite the need to register with EA, you can't build a team on other versions and then take control of them on the Switch. This is exactly the kind of vision fans had for a fully-fledged version that can be taken on the go, so it's a big shame it couldn't be made to happen this year. There's no doubt this will be made a reality in future editions, and it's likely that time was a factor here, but that won't exactly lessen the blow for those with that dream in mind. It's certainly great to see the mode return to a Nintendo system, but many would have hoped for a less streamlined version, again clearly based off of old versions of these long-standing staples of the brand. Next year, we're told.

Image for

Unfortunately, though, there's an even more disappointing drawback in play with the Switch version of FIFA 18. There is no way to invite your friends to an online game, and thus you're stuck playing strangers in terms of online play. This just seems utterly ridiculous. Although with Nintendo's very lacking online infrastructure (so far), it is difficult to know exactly why this utterly integral component of FIFA was omitted. Did EA underestimate its importance? It's very unlikely, and that's all one can really say about it with any certainty.

However, it's definitely the case that its absence could prove costly for both parties. It's not a good indicator that the Switch is going to maintain parity of quality and experience in terms of gameplay and features moving forward. It's quite obvious that EA Sports relies heavily on the tools Sony and Microsoft provide in terms of online infrastructure, so it's bewildering (though not exactly surprising) that they've struggled with a different set here. Major improvements must be implemented in next year's edition, by which time Switch owners will in theory be paying for their online service.

Screenshot for FIFA 18 on Nintendo Switch

Cubed3 Rating

7/10
Rated 7 out of 10

Very Good - Bronze Award

Rated 7 out of 10

It's difficult to reflect on FIFA 18 for Nintendo Switch. On the one hand, this is definitely the most fully-fledged portable version of FIFA ever. When docked, it performs extremely well, delivering crisp 1080p, 60 frames per second visuals, with enough extra polish to keep it in touching distance of the more powerful consoles. However, it's disappointing that old code couldn't be given the same touch-ups that FIFA 18 received within modes on other consoles, particularly when it comes to Ultimate Team. Add this to the cramp issues for handheld and Joy-Con control methods, and the lack of friend invites for online play, and it seems that a lot of wind has been taken out of the sails. Committed FIFA fans could quite rightly argue this shouldn't be a full-priced release, especially if next year's edition turns out to be that much better. However, there's no doubt that many football fans will still see this an essential buy.

Developer

EA Sports

Publisher

EA

Genre

Sport

Players

1

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  7/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  0 (0 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Comments

No friend invites. Incredible.

Can't help but feel Nintendo needs to step in as well tho. It's on them to put a solid and developer-friendly online infrastructure in place, and there should be no reason why a game like this doesn't have friend invites. Not letting EA off lightly here, but if part of the reason is due to the online system itself and EA not having much luck with it/finding it difficult, Nintendo really needs to be stepping in to ensure a feature like this is in place for a game like this. It's such a basic feature to play online with mates tho, that it's almost laughable it's not even included here.

Azuardo said:
No friend invites. Incredible.

Can't help but feel Nintendo needs to step in as well tho. It's on them to put a solid and developer-friendly online infrastructure in place, and there should be no reason why a game like this doesn't have friend invites. Not letting EA off lightly here, but if part of the reason is due to the online system itself and EA not having much luck with it/finding it difficult, Nintendo really needs to be stepping in to ensure a feature like this is in place for a game like this. It's such a basic feature to play online with mates tho, that it's almost laughable it's not even included here.


Yep! I tried to allude to this. While some might feel critical that EA would claim its 'fully fledged' without such an integral feature, it's really on Nintendo to make online features as easy as they are on Microsoft and Sony architecture. If it was that straight forward, invites would be in this edition. Whether it was rushed or a case of this 'transition period' causing problems - it's basically the last compromise we should have put up with. It more or less confirms what everyone is already worried about. If even the first party games have rigid systems for friend invites, what can we expect from the rest? Clearly EA didn't get much help, perhaps they should have lowered the price anyway, given the build is based on several years ago. 

I hesitate to say this, but perhaps they should have just forgotten about it this year. EA have tried to indicate the success of this title will influence whether more sport titles make it to the system. But it's not fair to basically suggest everyone needs to get involved in a game said to be up to PS4/XB1 standards, but actually has some glaring holes. Who is this helping? There's plenty of negativity surrounding this omission already. Since the importance of its success is well documented, it only feels like we're being catapulted back to Wii U standards of expectation from third party online experiences. Please no.

( Edited 02.10.2017 15:59 by The Strat Man )

EA does itself no favours by not making parity with the other versions by not including the story mode too tho. It's bold to say it needs to sell if we want more (Capcom pulled that shit with its £40 SF2 port), but for god's sake, at least put in modes the other versions have. Lack of friend invites is just icing it off.

I was incredibly skeptical on Friday, I got it on release and instantly thought it was a pile of trash, choppy and stuttery animations, old (and out of date) commentary, glitches, not being able to match with friends online and a cut back season mode makes it laughable especially when looking at its twin brothers  (XB1/PS4 version).

However less than one week on and i've put close to 30 hours into FIFA already. Strangely I actually don't want to play it docked, I'd rather play a superior football game on my 4KTV (PES). I am on the road a lot and have a long commute so having a portable version of FIFA is the only the reason i purchased it. I was going to hold off but I had to try it! 

I would have probably scored it more scathingly though, around a 5 or 6 at most.  

Apparently EA was pressed on the matter of friend requests and basically gave a non-answer, dodging the severity of the issue. That makes me think it is Nintendo not providing enough access to online servers/network options/etc and EA just didn't want to be seen to be slagging Nintendo off Smilie

Adam Riley [ Operations Director :: Senior Editor :: Cubed3 Limited ]
Word of Adam | Voice123 Profile | AdamC3 on Twitter

Comment on this article

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
K-Pop Korner - The Best of Korean Music
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
Adam Riley, Azuardo, hinchjoie

There are 3 members online at the moment.