Pokémon Silver Version (Game Boy Color) Review

By Tomas Barry 22.12.2017

Review for Pokémon Silver Version on Game Boy Color

After the success Game Freak had with Pokémon Red / Blue, it was inevitable that a second wave of titles would emerge soon enough, seeking to capitalise on the first generation's huge popularity. Pokémon Gold and Silver released in Japan in 1999, followed by Australia and North America in 2000, and Europe in 2001 - for the Game Boy Colour. Since many Pokémon fans believe Gold and Silver to be the pinnacle of the series, it comes as no surprise that they have now found their way onto the Nintendo 3DS Virtual Console. Of course, they have been revisited before, on the Nintendo DS with Pokémon HeartGold / SoulSilver back in 2010, but those remakes pulled in many other aspects from the series at large, meaning that they don't exactly evoke maximum nostalgia. By contrast, these eShop versions, available for a very reasonable £8.99, are just as they were in the past. However, are Pokémon Gold and Silver exactly as you remember?

The games are not exactly the same as before, actually. One rather essential modification is the ability to trade and battle Pokémon via local wireless, which ensures that a complete Pokedex can be achieved through the same means as originally (albeit without a link-cable!) - by trading back with the eShop versions of Pokémon Red and Blue. It's nice that the core functionality is all here, in uncompromised form. That said, though, going above and beyond, by adding online support for these features could have provided an even greater incentive to revisit Johto. While there are plenty of worthwhile modern entries worth gathering your friends online for, like Pokémon X and Y, and Sun and Moon - battling and trading with the first and second-generation titles has its own nostalgia-based appeal, so it seems like a missed opportunity not to have online support. At least trading and battling between these first and second-generation re-releases is possible, and they are even compatible with Pokémon Bank.

Screenshot for Pokémon Silver Version on Game Boy Color

All the mainline Pokémon iterations, from the Game Boy to 3DS, have expanded in one way or another, but they still retain the core framework set out by the original adventures, Red and Blue, which is a testament to the strength of that original formula. However, for many life-long fans, it was the second-generation titles, Pokémon Gold and Silver, that struck the absolute perfect balance. One hundred Pokémon were added, bringing the total number up to a healthy (but not ridiculous) 251, whilst also introducing two new types in Steel and Dark. Actually, though, a surprising number of new concepts were implemented in these follow-up adventures, as well.

Perhaps the most useful one was the ability of Pokémon to hold items, which enabled a variety of perks, such as stat enhancements and automatic healing, to occur in battle. This added an extra layer of tactics, allowing for more personalised approaches to each encounter. Another significant addition was the breeding and egg system, which was an entirely new way to collect Pokémon. In some cases, it was the only way to acquire them, and these Pokémon could also inherit certain moves, including TMs and HMs, adding further depth, whilst also encouraging a lot of experimentation.

Screenshot for Pokémon Silver Version on Game Boy Color

Elsewhere, there was also a new calendar and clock system, which kept tabs on the time, implementing day and night phases in the world, whilst also tracking the days of the week. This meant that there were events that only occurred on a specific day, as well as creatures that could only be discovered at certain points in time. While, quite wisely, these elements weren't over-used, and in fact the whole game could be completed without encountering them, the presence of these time-sensitive events certainly helped the world to feel much more alive and dynamic. It was an exciting inclusion, particularly for a handheld experience of that era. Another very welcome addition was the mobile phone system, which could be used to contact previously defeated foes for a rematch - a very handy feature for upping the XP.

Screenshot for Pokémon Silver Version on Game Boy Color

However, beyond this array of new features, much of the fans' fondness for Pokémon Gold and Silver could also be credited to the Johto region itself, where the majority of the game takes place. It remains one of the most distinct and memorable regions from any Pokémon iteration, which is saying something, considering the limited graphical ability of the Game Boy Colour. The developer based the setting of Johto on the Kansai and Tōkai regions of Japan and, as such, it features a very interesting, traditional, and well-accentuated Japanese aesthetic. It's especially successful when compared to the Kanto region (the setting for Red and Blue), which players gain access to again after completing the main quest. By comparison, that region is nowhere near as pronounced and lacks the same sense of character. However, it's nonetheless a fantastic extension to Gold and Silver to be able to return to the original stomping ground.

Screenshot for Pokémon Silver Version on Game Boy Color

Cubed3 Rating

8/10
Rated 8 out of 10

Great - Silver Award

Rated 8 out of 10

When Pokémon Gold and Silver first released on the Game Boy Colour, over seventeen years ago now, they capitalised and consolidated the franchise's massive worldwide appeal in a big way. Revisiting them today could be viewed as a slight risk for long-term fans that were part of that original movement. They, quite rightly, may worry about disrupting their deep-set nostalgic fondness for these entries. However, and surprisingly, the reality is quite the opposite. These extremely affordable eShop downloads have aged extremely well, and once players have invested a few hours, they will probably find it challenging to peel themselves away from their 3DS systems. Considering how affordable these two titles are, only those who have already returned to Johto, on the Nintendo DS with Pokémon HeartGold and SoulSilver, may want to give this one a miss. The rest will not regret reintroducing themselves to this expertly tuned formula for the ages.

Developer

Game Freak

Publisher

Nintendo

Genre

Turn Based RPG

Players

2

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  7/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  9/10 (1 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Comments

Comments are currently disabled

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
jesusraz

There are 1 members online at the moment.