Mutant Mudds Collection (Nintendo Switch) Review

By Adam Riley 30.12.2017

Review for Mutant Mudds Collection on Nintendo Switch

Mutant Mudds started out as a Nintendo 3DS project, making great use of the system's 3D depth by creating a layered approach that allowed gamers to not just work through the tough as nails platform adventure on one plane, but flick from the current viewpoint to both the background and foreground. It was spruced up for a Deluxe release after that, and eventually an even tougher update came out, in the form of Mutant Mudds: Super Challenge. Now, those original two highly regarded platformers come together, complete with a new Match-3 puzzle offering, Mudd Blocks, in a compilation on Nintendo Switch, quite aptly known as Mutant Mudds Collection.

Fans of retro platform exploits are going to absolutely adore both of the Mutant Mudds entries, and rightly so. Renegade Kid, from which Atooi was borne, crafted a difficult experience for fans of classics from the NES era, refined it to near perfection, and then went one step further and followed up the polished Mutant Mudds Deluxe with something for the more hardcore gamers out there that has squeezed every last drop out of the original. Lead character, Max, was transformed from potential star in a 3D platformer (as seen in early demos) to a sort of "12-bit" hero, in a game that played like 8-bit, but looked more 16-bit in appearance.

In Deluxe, he has to fight his way across complex levels that were specially layered to take advantage of the Nintendo 3DS technology, but thankfully still work almost as well on non-3D systems thanks to the clever fading used in the background and foreground, and certain key indicators to show when enemies are transitioning into your current plane, to avoid unfortunate deaths. The aim is still to blast away at enemies, whilst gathering 100 diamonds in each stage, with the accrual of gems helping unlock more levels, and even upgrades for accessing hidden areas. Nothing has changed on that front.

Screenshot for Mutant Mudds Collection on Nintendo Switch

Mutant Mudds: Super Challenge takes the level-based format of its predecessor, but removes any introductory stages and goes straight for the jugular, throwing in more monsters and spikes around levels, flinging obstacles galore around that require absolute precision leaps, and even a heavy dose of memorising level layouts, to proceed successfully, with an added inclusion of boss battles and some ghost levels to bring more variety to the table.

Now, whether or not the added challenge is welcomed will come down to the individual. Nowadays, with trickier games having plenty of checkpoints, when moving from the original Mudds - which is highly enjoyable, even with Max's sometimes awkward jump, and shorter than desired hover feature - to the Super Challenge version - where those former 'quirks' become sources of sheer pain and annoyance in places - it will come as a real shock to the system, especially given the sparse use of checkpoints, leading to plenty of repeated expeditions through stages. Purists will rejoice, more casual platform fans need to approach with caution.

As for Mudd Blocks - seemingly the newcomer, but actually more of a Mudds re-skin of niche puzzler, Bomb Monkey from 3DS - it looks like a Puzzle League clone, but instead of matching three or more of a kind to clear blocks immediately, they must be connected horizontally, vertically, or in L shapes first, and then removed once a bomb becomes available as the next item drop. This removes the addictive, quick-fire nature of similar titles, instead making it more of a slow, methodical build up, carefully placing the correct blocks around and hoping a bomb appears before things pile up too much. There are several modes available to try and spice things up, with one where different numbers needing to be cleared in the correct order probably the most engaging, but ultimately Mudd Blocks is definitely the weakest part of the package.

Screenshot for Mutant Mudds Collection on Nintendo Switch

Cubed3 Rating

Rated 8 out of 10

Great - Silver Award

Rated 8 out of 10

The coming together of two fantastic platform adventures, and a decent enough puzzle entry, means that Mutant Mudds Collection is well worth checking out for those that are up for a very strict challenge. It has some drawbacks in terms of how smooth the lead character jumps, but the majority of the game is so well constructed that those loving retro style outings will quickly become accustomed to the games' approach and quickly fall for its classic charm.






2D Platformer



C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  8/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  0 (0 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   


Comments are currently disabled

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?

There are 1 members online at the moment.