Cubed3 Nintendo gaming, Wii and DS

Sonic Classic Collection (Nintendo DS) Review

Review for Sonic Classic Collection on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

Sonic Classic Collection, in theory, is something that I've dreamed of for a long time. I've always wanted to own the classic Mega Drive Sonic games on a handheld format, but this hasn't been an option before - we can pretty much disregard the infamous Game Boy Advance port of Sonic the Hedgehog. On the basis of the final product, however, it seems that I should probably keep on dreaming just a little while longer. Nothing's ever as good in reality afterall, is it?

Sonic Classic Collection is flawed. As an avid fan of everybody's favourite needlemouse from an early age, I've witnessed his highs and lows as everybody else has. No matter what happens, though, I know that nothing can change the fact that Sonic, as a series, still has to its name four of the finest examples of gaming ever created, in the Mega Drive titles. The existence of Sonic Classic Collection does not alter this, but there is something disturbing about the idea that those four games, combined into one package, could not turn out perfectly. Sonic Mega Collection did it. Sonic Jam did it. Sonic Classic Collection should have been a shoe-in for one of the easiest, and most well-deserved, high scores ever handed out, but something has clearly gone a bit wonky along the way.

The games that make up the collection - Sonic the Hedgehog, Sonic the Hedgehog 2, Sonic the Hedgehog 3, Sonic & Knuckles, and the additional interpretations of the second and third games originally made possible by the cartridge lock-on function of Sonic & Knuckles - are not to blame for the package's downfall. They're the same titles that unleashed great amounts of joy in the 1990s, the same that are responsible for much of the adulation that Sonic receives to this day. The problem lies in the way that they have been presented, almost as if they have been put through a glitch filter before the cartridges were pressed. They are marred by slowdown, niggles and omitted features, none of which were issues with the original releases. Why are they here now, then, decades later?

The slowdown is the most prominent downside about Sonic Classic Collection. Basically, if your main character is occupying the screen with more than one or two enemies at a time, it's susceptible to drops in framerate. When you get hit and your rings tip all over the screen, the games chug along for a second or two. When you move underwater, your character travels even slower than you might expect, even taking into account the reduced speed in that terrain. Better yet, should you choose that Sonic should be followed by Tails in Sonic 2 or Sonic 3 (& Knuckles), you are at constant risk of entering unwanted slow motion due to the extra character occupying the screen. It's the last thing you want in a game based around a character who is supposed to be the fastest thing alive. Also bear in mind that DS has had two Sonic Rush titles created especially for it, that are far faster and more advanced visually, that do not suffer from this sort of thing.

Graphical glitches are rife throughout, from the small and innocuous (occasional fragmented lettering in the limited amount of text that there is), to the disappointing (background items flickering and changing colours as you move), to the potentially infuriating (key elements becoming obscured, such as some of the pixel-thin arrows needed to defeat Sonic 2's Aquatic Ruin Zone boss, blending right into the background). It appears that the games have not been scaled properly to match DS' resolution, resulting in a huge bundle of visual mishaps that, while being harmless the vast majority of the time, simply should not be there. Peering at the credits goes some way towards figuring out why the issues exist. The collection does not appear to have been created entirely in-house, with the lead DS programmer being one Stephan Dittrich - creator of the Mega Drive DS emulator jEnesisDS. The games have not been properly ported; they are being emulated, and not even through a SEGA-created emulator.

Screenshot for Sonic Classic Collection on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

Other glitches are more severe - there are collision detection issues. I passed through things that I should not have been able to on more than one occasion. To my benefit, Sonic sailed through the electric field wielded by Sonic 2's Casino Night Zone boss unharmed; to my detriment, I tumbled through the bridge destroyed at the beginning of Sonic 3's Angel Island Zone main boss battle - before it had even collapsed. These occurrences are infrequent but, again, should be nowhere near the game in the first place.

Any multiplayer functionality that the later games introduced are now missing. It's a massive shame, as the race modes could have benefitted from being spread out over two systems so that players could play in full screen, rather than being restricted to split screens as in the originals. Due to DS' second screen, the opponent's progress could even have been shown on the bottom screen to retain the same feeling. These modes could have made for some fun local and/or online multiplayer, but alas. Of course, this also means that you cannot partake in some co-op action, as you could in the originals by plugging in a second controller.

Emulation cannot be blamed for everything; it cannot justify the poor use of the touch screen, for one thing. Its main purpose is to display little blurbs describing the game that you're playing, as well as letting you check the controls. There isn't exactly much that could have been done with it here, to be fair, and at least extraneous touch gameplay features have not been shoved in for the sake of it. What is annoying, though, is that you cannot merely press the Start button to pause the action - you must press the icon on the touch screen, which is just impractical in a game that is entirely button-controlled otherwise. The touch screen is home to one of the good features of Sonic Classic Collection, though; it is through touch-based options that you can save and load progress in Sonic the Hedgehog and Sonic the Hedgehog 2, allowing you to kick off from the start of your current Act should you need to shut off in a hurry. Sonic the Hedgehog 3 utilises the same battery back-up save function that it did in the original, so the option is not applicable here.

There are certainly things that Sonic Classic Collection handles very well; surprisingly, the most graphically challenging sections of the originals, the 3D special stages, work absolutely flawlessly, which makes it all the more painful that the main action is not so smooth. Play the game with a single main character and things look up, until you encounter other causes of the slowdown, and Sonic & Knuckles seems to fare generally better than the rest of the package on this front. The music is still as fantastic as it ever was. For all that is wrong with Sonic Classic Collection, the four games contained within are still great fun - the problem is, there are a number of issues that crop up far too close for comfort, which holds the whole thing back and will, unquestionably, detract a lot of fun from the games for fans.

Screenshot for Sonic Classic Collection on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

Gameplay

The classic gameplay is there, but it is covered in a paste of glitches, and slowdown does not help proceedings at all.

Graphics

In stills, they look as lovely as they ever did. In motion, when there's too much going on, slowdown and graphical glitches are common.

Sound

The music is still masterful and an example of what videogame music should be.

Value

Four classic games at a budget price is great value for money; it would've been even better value were it not for the frequency of slowdown and other flaws.

Cubed3 Rating

5/10
Rated 5 out of 10

Mediocre

About this score

If you desperately need handheld versions of the classic Sonic titles, you have no alternative than to buy Sonic Classic Collection. However, the true greatness of the games on offer here does not get to shine through properly as there are a number of a issues, from glitchiness and slowdown to removed features. The Mega Drive Sonic games continue to be best experienced on the television, whether it be by booting up the GameCube's Sonic Mega Collection, downloading digital versions on your home console, or even dusting off the trusty old Mega Drive itself.

Read and post comments

 Buy Sonic Classic Collection (Nintendo DS) Buy Sonic Classic Collection (Nintendo DS)

Share this Review Share this Review

11.05.2010

13

6188

Games you may also like...

Developer

SEGA

Publisher

SEGA

Genre

2D Platformer

Players

1

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  5/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  6/10 (3 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Who wants this game?

No members want this game yet - be the first to add to your wishlist!
I want this game View All

Reader comments - add yours today Comments on this Review

There are no replies to this review yet. Why not be the first?
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

They are pretty lazy ports, which is a huge shame when there are efforts like MegaMan Zero Collection on the way which look really smooth and great and thorough.

Still, I can play Sonic 3 & Knuckles on the go, and that's pretty heavenly for me Smilie

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

A fair enough review IMO.

I saw some notes from people having played the game, that the collection takes advantage of the additional horse power of the DSi when played on aforementioned console, and then the slowdown and glitches are less noticeable (but still there). A DSi enhanced game then.

Cubed3 Limited Staff :: Review and Feature Writer
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

Kafei2006 said:
I saw some notes from people having played the game, that the collection takes advantage of the additional horse power of the DSi when played on aforementioned console, and then the slowdown and glitches are less noticeable (but still there). A DSi enhanced game then.

I can verify this having tried it myself. One funny thing worth noting though is that Sonic 3's Special Stages run (much) WORSE on the DSi and better on the DS, whereas most of the game runs best on the DSi.

Very weird.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

Its strange how i have an R4 with the megadrive roms emulated and it runs better than the legit version...

Senior ModeratorStaff Member

welshwuff said:
Its strange how i have an R4 with the megadrive roms emulated and it runs better than the legit version...

The versions in Classic Collection aren't even proper ports, they're bad emulations.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

So basically it's the GBA baaad ports ported over into one DS cart?

Senior ModeratorStaff Member

EdEN said:
So basically it's the GBA baaad ports ported over into one DS cart?

No, trust me when I say it's nowhere near as bad as Sonic Genesis GBA.

The lag is noticable, and there are many features like multiplayer and Debug modes removed, but unlike Sonic Genesis on GBA the game is mostly very playable, especially on DSi.

Twitter | C3 Writer/Moderator | Backloggery

The GBA only ported Sonic 1 to my recollection, but its a terrible attempt to milk money, which im sure it has.

For those of you in doubt and still want to buy it, then buy it from Gamestation and if no likey, 10 day it!

Yeah, this is nowhere near Sonic GBA bad. The core games are still fantastic - but there are a lot of glitches in the way that block this from being the collection it should have been.

lazy port. typicall sega....when will you get it right...


Mario, Mega Man and Rayman FTW!!!

Comment on this review

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.

Follow this topic Follow this topic

Keep up with new comments with the RSS feed for this topic, or subscribe via email above.
Turqoise Radio - Cubed3's Glass to the Wall
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Latest news and updatesSite Feed
Vote on our latest community pollNintendo Poll
Vote: Which eShop Games will you Download this Week?
Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse
Disney Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two
Disney Epic Mickey: Power of Illusion
Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl Demo
F-Zero: Maximum Velocity
Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams
Golden Sun
I am in the Movie
Mario Golf: World Tour Demo
My Exotic Farm
My Farm
Nintendo Pocket Football Club
Putty Squad
Tiny Games - Knights & Dragons
Member of the weekMember of the Week
This week's top member is jres80, awarded the most stars for great posts.
Online Play and ChatOnline Nintendo Play & Chat
General Chatroom: Click here to chat Wii U Nintendo Network Codes - Find other Nintendo Wii U users 3DS Nintendo Network Codes - Find other Nintendo 3DS users
Listen to our Nintendo Jukebox - Classic Mario, Zelda, Metroid songs and more Nintendo news and reviews on the move