Cubed3 Nintendo gaming, Wii and DS

Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon (Nintendo DS) Review

Review for Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

If it wasn't for Super Smash Bros. Melee, most Western gamers would probably still be ignorant about the Fire Emblem series. Thankfully, the Fire Emblem characters that starred in the aforementioned best-selling GameCube game, Marth and Roy, both gained such popularity among gamers that Nintendo decided to give the series a chance outside of Japan. They presented us with the latest installment at that time, Fire Emblem Rekka no Ken for the Game Boy Advance (Fire Emblem: Blazing Swords in the language of Shakespeare), known simply as Fire Emblem in our territories. However, though all following episodes released since have come to the West, we have remained complete strangers to the six other games released before Rekka no Ken, including the episodes from which Marth and Roy came in the first place. Fast forward to 2008, when Nintendo and Intelligent Systems finally brought the episode that started it all to Western territories, remade for the Nintendo DS to celebrate the 25th anniversary of the Famicom.

Once upon a time, the continent of Akaneia was conquered by Medeus, lord of the dragon-kin, plunging the land's people into death and despair. A hero from the Altea region soon appeared and freed the people of the continent by slaying the Shadow Dragon, but a century later the evil returned, teamed with a sorcerer who sought to rule the world. With the evil threatening to spread into Akaneia again, the responsibility of defeating the Shadow Dragon fell upon the only remaining heir of the original hero's bloodline, the king of Altea. Wielding his ancestor's sword, Falchion, he sets out to slay the dragon once more. Meanwhile, the king's young son Prince Marth trains in fencing, waiting for his father to return from war in the neighbouring country of Gra. That is, until the day that enemy soldiers of Gra invade the castle, attempting to imprison Marth and seize the throne. Refusing to surrender, Marth fights the soldiers away from the throne room, where he meets his sister, Princess Elice. She informs Marth that their father was defeated in battle.

The castle lost to enemy forces, they are forced to escape quickly. They split up; Elice looks for their mother, while Marth goes in search of any surviving allies. The prince quickly meets with other soldiers and makes his way to the exit, fighting off enemies as he goes. As if the pressure could not get any higher, Marth's ally Cain returns from Gra's battlefield carrying the king's last words: Marth is to wield the Falchion and free Akaneia once again. Further bad news comes as the king's confidant, Malledus, appears from the castle alone in the aftermath, explaining that Elice - who he was to protect - had decided to stay behind to give Marth time to escape, knowing that he, as sole heir to Falchion, is the only hope of salvation for Akaneia. Accepting his sister's sacrifice, Marth promises to become a worthy wielder of Falchion and avenge the fallen by defeating Medeus. The group leaves for Talys, an ally island kingdom to the east, and thus Marth's quest to free Akaneia begins...

Being a 20-year-old 8-bit tactical role playing game, you might expect Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon's plot to be rather thin by today's standards. Surprisingly though, even at the very start of the series, Intelligent Systems got it right. It's not quite on par with the GBA outings that we know and love, and nowhere near as convoluted as the GameCube and Wii installments, but it still manages to keep you wondering what will happen next and playing to the very end. This DS version also adds a couple of 'Prologue' chapters that serve as a tutorial, on top of expanding upon the original plot. Some 'Gaiden' ('side story' in Japanese) or secret chapters are also new and further expand the original plot (these chapters should not to be confused with Fire Emblem Gaiden for the Famicom; they are unrelated). It does not, however, include 'Book Two' of the story, that featured in the previous enhanced remake, Fire Emblem : Monshô no Nazo on the Super Famicom. Book Two continues the story after the events of the original Famicom game, and will serve as the plot for the most recently announced Fire Emblem DS title.

The gameplay has seen some very interesting improvements. All previous Fire Emblem titles so far have relied on a D-pad or analogue stick to move a cursor around, plus buttons for actions. However, we are now on DS, so touch screen controls for giving orders to your units were to be expected. It was highly disappointing to find that pointer controls were omitted from the Wii episode; it seemed to be a no-brainer to include these controls in a tactical RPG. Shadow Dragon corrects it all, by at last allowing you to give orders faster than ever, thanks to good touch screen controls. Tap a unit, touch where you want it to go or trace its path, give it its final orders by tapping your chosen command, and there you are. Simple, and yet very efficient.

The core mechanics are as you would expect of a Fire Emblem game. You take the reins of an army, and from this army select a number of units per mission, presented in the form of chapters. Each chapter has its own objective. It could be rallying to a point, seizing a location, wiping out the whole enemy army, or 'simply' surviving a certain number of turns. Generally in Shadow Dragon you'll be spending your time capturing locations. Some maps have a fog of war or take place at night, which reduces the viewing distance of your units, preventing you from seeing where all the enemy units are.

Screenshot for Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

As in most role playing games, your units each have experience points and levels, as well as statistics that define their strengths and weaknesses. Every battle a unit takes part in earns them experience points, win or lose, though victors take away the greater spoils, of course. Units gain a level upon collecting 100 experience points, thus improving a few of their statistics.

You and your enemies take it in turns to move your units a set number of grid places on a map and give them orders (wait, attack, use an item, etc.). The terrain affects your units' behavior while they are on the move, as well as during battle. Sand, for example, slows the movement of certain units, such as horse riders. Forests give you more cover to dodge enemy hits, while castles raise your evasion and defence.

Battles commence when a unit stands on a square that is within range of an opposing unit (the range depending on what sort of weapon you are wielding) and is given an attack order. The battles themselves follow rules akin to rock/paper/scissors (the swords beat the axes, the axes beat the spears and the spears beat the swords, the magics being in a similar vein). How your hits affect the enemies, and how theirs affect your units, depends on the relations between the weapons they have equipped, their stats (a fast unit will dodge more easily, a unit with high defence may not be affected by a hit at all, etc.), and the terrain they're standing on. Weapons also break after a certain number of uses, the amount depending on the weapon itself. Usually the more powerful or deadly a weapon is, the more fragile it is.

Any improvements found in later episodes, such as the ability to carry an injured allied unit on the back of another to safety, have been left out of this remake, possibly because they could have ruined the difficulty balance without significant reworks to the missions. Shadow Dragon also suffers from stat growth rates that are occasionally horrendous; knights in heavy armour that become victim to low defence through the random nature of statistic growth, for example, are particularly frustrating. Though statistics have always been randomised in this way in Fire Emblem, it is at least refined and less annoying in later titles.

There are new unit classes in this episode. Firstly there are the Chameleons, which can usefully take the appearance of another of your units, allowing it to temporarily take on the mantle of another class. Then there are Ballisticians which, as their name suggests, use ballistae. Unlike in other titles, you don't pick up ballistae from the enemies' hands; instead they are 'carried' (as weird as it may seem, since they are huge and all...) by the Ballisticians and break after a reasonable amount of uses, like any weapon in the game.

Screenshot for Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

Another new function present here is the ability to re-class your characters. At any moment between chapters you can now convert one of your units into a completely different class. There are restrictions as to what a unit can become, though. For example, your myrmidon could swap over to being a mage, but it won't be able to become a knight. Reclassifying a unit modifies its stats, losing and gaining some depending on the target class. I found that it usually ends up screwing the unit up, because the unit was trained for a specific class before and, hopefully, gained points in the stats that were relevant to its particular class. Turning a myrmidon with poor magic resistance into a mage, for example, wouldn't be a wise move, because the resistance bonus he'll gain from the re-class won't be enough to ensure its survival in battle against other mages, and he'll end up being a crappy example of the class. The re-class can be beneficial for other class changes, though, and it can be useful in situations where you really need a high level unit in a class that you have not got covered - and it's handy for one chapter in particular, if you opted to ignore a certain class.

The Fire Emblem series is well known for its difficulty. The usual rule of 'lose a unit and it's lost forever' of the series still applies. This episode, however, feels a bit easier overall, except maybe for the conditions you have to meet to get access to the new Gaiden chapters. The experience point growth rate is also rather low, compared to say...Blazing Swords; it's closer to the Famicom original on that point (and to the Japan-exclusive Fire Emblem: Fuuin no Tsurugi for the GBA). What definitely makes the game significantly easier is the possibility to permanently save your game whenever you want, unlike the auto-quick save from the GBA episodes, which left little place for trial and error. It differs from Radiant Dawn in that you can't save as many times as you want during a chapter, because each save requires that one of your characters is standing on special map save point tiles which disappear once they have been used to save your game. Therefore, the number of times you're allowed to save your game during a chapter basically depends on how many of those points there are on the map, but despite this limit it still makes the game much easier. Each of the three regular save files can host two 'map saves', so it leaves plenty of room for trial and error (if your last map save put you in an irreversible dangerous situation, you can still go back to an earlier map save point).

The game still has the local multiplayer mode, but what you really want to try out is the new online mode that lets you battle against friends or anyone through the Internet. Both multiplayer modes play identically. Battles are fought with squads made up of five characters selected from your save files. Multiplayer matches take place on one of six different multiplayer maps, chosen at random, which may or may not feature obstacles such as fog of war - also random. The goal is simply to destroy the opponent's team. Another nice twist is that, when battling against friends, there's voice chat. Neat! When trying to battle against strangers, though, get ready for a long wait before finally finding an opponent.

A strange online feature - which I admit I have not had the opportunity to test - is the 'loan' option. Simply put, it lets you 'loan' some of your units to your friends, or use units that your friends have loaned to you. You upload the units you want to make available for your friends (those that you have exchanged friend codes with), or download units from your friends' catalogue, and you can then use them in one of your own save files. It could be interesting to see how your pals have trained their units differently. The twist is that if you borrow a character, restrictions are placed upon your team options. If you take a Marth, for example, your own Marth won't be available for battle for as long as the loaned one is in your team. You can't have the same character in use twice. The final addition to the online mode is an online shop that lets you buy items. It acts just like a regular shop in the game except what it has to offer is updated daily.

While Shadow Dragon is in 2D like the other handheld Fire Emblem titles, the graphical upgrade since the Game Boy Advance is immediately noticeable. The maps are more detailed, the tiles benefiting from an increased pixel count; 24x24, instead of the 16x16 found in previous 2D iterations. The map character sprites also benefit from this. One of the complaints about the GBA episodes was that the low-resolution and small size of the screen made it hard to distinguish some units from the others, especially on first model GBAs, which didn't have backlit screens. Now that the sprites are of a higher resolution, and all DS models are equipped with clearer screens, that issue is no more. The dual screen aspect of the DS is also put to great use, with the top screen used to display all information about the current chapter, the map, and the selected terrain or units, keeping the bottom screen clear for all the action.

The sprites in battle, though, look significantly different. They now look like pre-rendered CG models, not unlike the technique used in Donkey Kong Country and Super Mario RPG. The animation is ultra smooth. What I don't like, though, are the models themselves. This might be a very subjective opinion, but I think they look like plastic, and because the backgrounds do not use the same modeling technique they do not blend so well into the overall picture. I prefer the old lower resolution 2D sprites from the GBA, which had already amazingly fluid animations. The critical hit sequences are not as spectacular as their GBA counterparts, either.

Screenshot for Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Nintendo DS - on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

On a similar note, I don't like the character art as much as I did on the GBA, and far less than the latest home console episodes. The tiny mugshots of the original Famicom version may even look better, in my opinion. Don't get me wrong, they look good in this DS remake, but I am used to seeing better from the series. It's even more disappointing with the knowledge that the character illustrations were drawn by manga master Masamune Shirow, of Appleseed and Ghost in the Shell fame.

The music in this game is great. By now we're used to hearing tracks from older episodes reappearing in later Fire Emblems. Here, it's the reverse situation. We finally get to hear where some of our favorite Fire Emblem tracks came from in the first place. Music in the series has always made the adventure feel epic, and Shadow Dragon is no exception. Taking advantage of the DS sound chip, it sounds even better than the Game Boy Advance titles which, despite its poor sound quality in some games, already had great Fire Emblem soundtracks. The sound effects are better too.

Overall, Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon is good, but it lacks some of the things that make the latest Fire Emblem titles so great. Expecting it to be on the level as Wii's Radiant Dawn would be unreasonable, but I expected it to be at least on par with the Game Boy Advance titles. It does not match up to GBA efforts for reasons mentioned above, but some improvements - touch screen controls, use of the dual screen and the online modes - are awesome additions to the series.

Screenshot for Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Nintendo DS- on Nintendo Wii U, 3DS games review

Gameplay

The touch screen controls are definitely a welcome addition, and make you wonder why it took so long for another episode to be announced (as well as why Wii pointer controls weren't incorporated into Radiant Dawn).

Graphics

It's more detailed than any other 2D episode in the series, but the battle sprites and character design are a bit disappointing and make you wish they had retained the graphical style of the GBA episodes, though with the added advantages that the DS' higher resolution screens allow. Overall the art doesn't look as good.

Sound

The music boasts great compositions and, like in all Fire Emblem games, make the overall experience feel epic. The better sound quality that DS affords helps the sound effects and music to sound better overall than GBA titles - and of course the original Famicom version.

Value

The map save points will save you some chapter restarts to avoid losing a precious unit, so it tends to make the game shorter, even though the game has a number of chapters similar to the latest installments. The online gameplay adds virtually unlimited value to the title, provided you can find someone to battle against.

Cubed3 Rating

8/10
Rated 8 out of 10

Great - Silver Award

About this score
Rated 8 out of 10

Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon is another quality addition to the series, but it doesn't feel as good as the latest installments because it lacks refinements made to the formula. It also panders to newcomers too much, ditching one of the elements that make the series so enjoyable to its hardcore fans in the process: the difficulty. Some new elements feel forced into the game to make it feel fresh and more accessible. Despite any disappointments, it's still a true Fire Emblem, and it remains a very good experience overall. It's an absolute must-have for any hardcore fans of the series that want to dive into the origins of the saga and discover the story behind Super Smash Bros. star Marth.

Read and post comments

 Buy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon (Nintendo DS) Buy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon (Nintendo DS)

Buy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on AmazonBuy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on Shop To Buy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on GameBuy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on TescoBuy Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon on The Hut

Share this Review Share this Review

30.05.2010

12

8424

Games you may also like...

Developer

Intelligent Systems

Publisher

Nintendo

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  8/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  8/10 (30 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date Out now   Australian release date Out now   

Reader comments - add yours today Comments on this Review

There are no replies to this review yet. Why not be the first?
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

An excellent, extremely thorough review for one of my favourite entries in the series! Great stuff Rudy Smilie

I can't wait for the next Fire Emblem DS remake Smilie

Adam Riley < Operations Director :: Senior Editor :: Cubed3 Limited >
Word of Adam | Voice123 Profile | AdamC3 on Twitter
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

Nice review! My biggest problem with the game was the difficulty. No challenge at all.

And then guess how you unlock the extra chapters? By having characters die. That's right, instead of completing a chapter quickly, or completing some difficult trigger, if you want to play the Gaiden chapters, you'll have to sacrifice your men. Fire Emblem actually rewarding bad play. Any Fire Emblem fan knows that half the challenge in the game is getting through without losing a single man.

I still loved the game, but moments like those that show that Nintendo was clearly trying to pander to the Brain Age crowd piss me off. Fire Emblem isn't casual. It never was. Don't make it to be.

C3 Moderator

I loved this game, playing on hardest level and trying to get that catapult guy to join you was quite the challenge I reckon, but overall it was pretty easy if you compare it to Path of Radiance or Radiant Dawn. The GBA games were excellent too!

Senior ModeratorStaff Member

Nice review and well justified score - I might give it a go given my total lack of knowledge on the Fire Emblem series, might be a good place to start!

Cubed3 Admin/Founder & Designer

Was thinking the same thing, J!

Great work Rudy. Smilie

Senior ModeratorStaff Member

That's definitely true. Path of Radiance (GC) and Radiant Dawn (Wii) are fantastic games, but far too daunting for anyone thinking of jumping into the series.

Shadow Dragon is perfect. Still has enough challenge to keep you going, but just about simpler than other entries so that it doesn't scare you off completely.

I started with the first Western GBA FE and got hooked instantly, then lost some interest whilst playing Sacred Stones simply because I had too many other games to focus on at the time. I did always think it was a shame Nintendo never brought over the very first GBA FE, Sword of Seals, since it didn't look graphically inferior to the other two and would have been a fine addition to the Western collection.

Adam Riley < Operations Director :: Senior Editor :: Cubed3 Limited >
Word of Adam | Voice123 Profile | AdamC3 on Twitter
Senior ModeratorStaff Member

jesusraz said:
That's definitely true. Path of Radiance (GC) and Radiant Dawn (Wii) are fantastic games, but far too daunting for anyone thinking of jumping into the series.

I hope you're not talking about the difficulty level... i found Path of Radiance easier than the first western FE... I didn't have too much trouble getting to the end without losing a unit... though i had a considerable of chapter restarts along the way (by FE standards i mean).

Maybe that was due to the fact that it wasn't my first Fire Emblem though.

Cubed3 Limited Staff :: Review and Feature Writer

Shadow Dragon is a great starting point for those new to the series.

Path of Radiance and Radiant Dawn on Hard are a great way to approach what could constitute a "perfect" run if you don't want anyone to die. Great value for the asking price since each one takes about 50+ to complete in hard with all units.

I agree with the review complete.y Shadow Dragon is ok, but compared to the newer installments, it's just too easy. Still, I love all Fire Emblem games. Can't wait for the next.

bl (guest) 23.06.2010 01:08#10

the game is awsome
SmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilieSmilie

Comment on this review

You can comment as a guest or join the Cubed3 community below: Sign Up for Free Account Login

Preview PostPreview Post Your Name:
Validate your comment
  Enter the letters in the image to validate your comment.
Submit Post

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.

Follow this topic Follow this topic

Keep up with new comments with the RSS feed for this topic, or subscribe via email above.
Turqoise Radio - Cubed3's Glass to the Wall
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Latest news and updatesSite Feed
Vote on our latest community pollNintendo Poll
Vote: Which eShop Games will you Download this Week?
Castlevania III: Dracula's Curse
Disney Epic Mickey 2: The Power of Two
Disney Epic Mickey: Power of Illusion
Etrian Odyssey Untold: The Millennium Girl Demo
F-Zero: Maximum Velocity
Giana Sisters: Twisted Dreams
Golden Sun
I am in the Movie
Mario Golf: World Tour Demo
My Exotic Farm
My Farm
Nintendo Pocket Football Club
Putty Squad
Tiny Games - Knights & Dragons
Member of the weekMember of the Week
This week's top member is jres80, awarded the most stars for great posts.
Online Play and ChatOnline Nintendo Play & Chat
General Chatroom: Click here to chat Wii U Nintendo Network Codes - Find other Nintendo Wii U users 3DS Nintendo Network Codes - Find other Nintendo 3DS users
Listen to our Nintendo Jukebox - Classic Mario, Zelda, Metroid songs and more Nintendo news and reviews on the move