Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail

Interview

Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail

From American candy favourites to quirky Japanese snacks, Candymail has built a colourful world of international treats and unusual gifts. Cubed3 caught up with founder and Managing Director Aaron Roberts on a passion for sourcing global goodies, plus a need to balance trends with customer favourites. Aaron also dives into the appeal of Japanese treats and plans for the future of Candymail.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley, Cubed3 Director: Candymail now lists 400k+ customers and 1500+ products from American to Japanese to worldwide. What was the original gap in the UK market you saw that made you start it?

Aaron Roberts, Founder and Managing Director of Candymail: The funny thing is, I wasn’t even thinking about a gap in the market!

I’ve always absolutely loved discovering cool and unusual products. Back when I was running my chain of gift shops, Gifted, I started getting interested in imported sweets and snacks. It was the packaging, the different flavours, the weird and wonderful varieties, and most importantly, seeing the reactions from customers when they discovered something they’d never seen before.
As soon as our first tiny delivery arrived, I was hooked. I knew immediately that I wanted to stock more and more!

By 2020, around 50% of our stores had become candy. Then lockdown hit. It was a genuinely scary time for retail, but it also presented an opportunity to do something completely different. We’d already seen how much customers loved these products in our shops, so we took that passion online, and Candymail was born.

It wasn’t some grand business strategy. It really started with me falling in love with the products and wanting everyone else to experience that same excitement of discovering something new.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: You have three distinct ways to shop — Mystery Boxes (American / Japanese / International), Build-Your-Own, and the wider Gift Hub with toys, fidgets and novelty. How do you balance curation vs customer control?

Aaron Roberts: This is a tricky one because I just love fun stuff! Honestly, one of my biggest challenges is keeping my own buying under control. I’ll see something ridiculous, colourful or completely unnecessary and immediately think, “I NEED that!” But from a customer’s perspective, we know everyone shops differently. Some people love the surprise of a Mystery Box, others know exactly what they want, and some just enjoy browsing until something catches their eye.

We’ve worked really hard to organise our website to make finding things as easy as possible. Customers can shop by brand, flavour, country or product type, depending on what they’re looking for.
We’re also developing more collections based on why someone is shopping, such as gifts for him, birthday treats, little surprises or something fun for a special occasion.

Ultimately, I want Candymail to be somewhere you can either find exactly what you came for or discover something you never knew existed but suddenly absolutely have to have!

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: How do you manage a live catalogue of 1500+ imported lines — from Jolly Ranchers to dagashi to Canadian chocolate — without it becoming unmanageable or stale?

Aaron Roberts: It’s incredibly difficult! And I don’t think there’s a perfect formula for it. I personally handle all the buying, but we’re very much a team when it comes to understanding what’s working. We communicate openly about what’s selling, what customers are asking for, and which products are starting to gain momentum.

Every week we review performance, identify opportunities, look at what needs replenishing and decide where we want to introduce something new. But we also make room for products that we simply love. Sometimes you spot something and just have a feeling it’s going to be brilliant. It’s probably more of an art than a science, and it’s definitely not something you can get right 100% of the time. Experience and instinct play a huge part.

The challenge is keeping such a huge range exciting without letting it become overwhelming, both for us and for our customers. But I genuinely love that challenge, especially the thrill of finding the next big thing.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: Your tagline is “You don’t choose the treats. You discover them.” What’s your rule for a good mystery mix — what has to be in every Classic vs Premium box to make it feel like value, not filler?

Aaron Roberts: For me, a great Mystery Box has to feel like a proper experience from the moment you open it.

We always aim for a really good balance of drinks, chocolate, sweets and savoury snacks. There should be some instantly recognisable favourites alongside more unusual products that you probably wouldn’t find easily elsewhere. It’s that combination of familiarity and discovery that makes a box exciting.

Our Japanese Mystery Boxes are slightly different because, for many customers, almost everything inside is going to be new to them. So the focus is on creating a good mix of flavours, textures and different types of treats. We especially love including products with cute, colourful kawaii-style packaging. Japanese snacks can be so visually brilliant that sometimes you almost don’t want to open them! Whether someone chooses Classic or Premium, the aim is the same: a box that feels varied, generous, fun and full of discoveries, rather than just a random selection of products.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: You’re importing from the US, Japan, Australia, Canada, Europe out of Great Yarmouth. What’s the hardest part — licensing, shelf-life, shipping costs, or just getting hold of viral TikTok stock in time?

Aaron Roberts: For us, one of the biggest challenges is identifying those hit products early enough and getting them to market before everyone else. That’s a huge part of our competitive edge. Our customers know that if something exciting is happening in the world of sweets and snacks, there’s a good chance we’ll be trying to get our hands on it.

But speed is only part of the challenge. Shipping costs have become incredibly difficult to manage in recent years, both when importing products into the UK and when delivering orders directly to customers. Finding amazing products is the fun part. Finding them at a price that still makes sense for us and offers good value to the customer is where things get complicated! There’s a constant balancing act between speed, availability, cost and keeping products affordable.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: The two biggest audiences behave very differently. What have you learned about what a Japan candy buyer wants vs an American candy buyer?

Aaron Roberts: There’s definitely a difference, and it’s fascinating to see. Our American candy customers tend to love the big, recognisable brands and flavours. Things like Cheetos, Dr Pepper Vanilla Float, Jolly Ranchers and all those classic American treats they’ve seen in films, on social media or heard people talking about.

There’s often a sense of familiarity, even if they haven’t actually tried the product before. They know the brand, but they’re excited to discover a flavour or variety they can’t normally get in the UK.
Japanese candy customers tend to be a little more adventurous, particularly when it comes to unusual flavours, savoury snacks and different textures. Japan does an incredible job of making food fun. You can find fascinating sweet-and-savoury combinations, beautifully designed packaging, limited-edition flavours and products that feel like a completely different experience from what we’re used to.

The packaging is also a massive part of the appeal. There’s a whole culture around cute characters, colourful designs and playful presentation that makes the products exciting before you’ve even tasted them. I think American candy is often about enjoying something you’ve always wanted to try, whereas Japanese candy is more about discovering something you never even imagined existed.
And I absolutely love both!

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: How do you decide between stocking a viral hype item (that might die in a month) versus a slow-burn classic like Ghana chocolate or Reese’s that always sells?

Aaron Roberts: We try to do both. Always! The classics are the backbone of the business. They’re the products people know, love and keep coming back for, so we want to make sure those are available as consistently as possible. But the hype products are incredibly exciting, and we always want to get involved early.

If we spot something taking off, we’ll often go big on it because being early can make a massive difference. Sometimes a product becomes absolutely enormous. PRIME was a great example of that, with sales running into the hundreds of thousands of units. Other times, something that looks like it’s going to be the next big thing turns out to be a little underwhelming and we only sell a handful! Interestingly, some hype products settle down after a few months and become perfectly good regular sellers in our catalogue.

It’s a combination of taking calculated risks and constantly reviewing the numbers. We monitor daily sales, sell-through rates and expected reorder requirements to make sure we’re reacting quickly. When you’ve got more than 1,500 product lines, even small buying mistakes can add up to a pretty big problem. But you can’t be afraid to take risks, because occasionally one of those risks turns into something massive!

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: 4,000+ Trustpilot reviews at 4.6/5, free candy over £35, free delivery over £50 – retention seems core. What actually keeps people coming back after the novelty of the first box wears off?

Aaron Roberts: I think there are three big reasons people keep coming back to us. Firstly, there’s always something new to discover. We’re adding exciting products pretty much every day, so even if you’ve shopped with us before, there’s a good chance you’ll find something you’ve never seen.

Our range is also a huge part of what makes us different. We don’t just focus on American sweets. We’ve got Japanese, Australian, Korean, Canadian, Indian and all sorts of other international treats. I think it’s difficult to find that breadth of choice in one place. At the same time, we work really hard to keep our bestselling favourites in stock because we know customers want to be able to come back and reorder the products they’ve fallen in love with. Secondly, we’re pretty efficient at getting orders out. Outside of the madness of Black Friday, around 99% of orders placed before 2pm are dispatched the same day. Customers really appreciate that reliability.

And thirdly, customer service. This is something I feel really strongly about. If there’s a problem, we just sort it out. Things occasionally go wrong in any business, but it’s how you deal with them that matters. We want customers to feel confident that they’re going to have a great experience every time they order from us. The first order might be about curiosity, but I think it’s the combination of exciting products, reliable delivery and knowing we’ll look after them that brings people back.

Adam Riley: You’ve expanded into squishies, fidgets, gadgets, novelty socks, games. Is Candymail still a candy company, or is it now a “fun stuff” gifting company?

Aaron Roberts: In a funny way, we’ve actually come full circle! Candymail originally grew out of my chain of gift and collectables shops called Gifted. We had stores in Norwich, Cambridge, Bury St Edmunds, King’s Lynn and Maidstone.

I’ve always loved selling fun, unusual products, licensed gifts and collectables. Our whole approach with Gifted was to create destination stores where people would walk in, discover something completely unexpected and think, “I didn’t know I needed that, but now I absolutely have to have it!”  That sense of discovery has always been at the heart of what I enjoy about retail.

When Candymail launched, we focused heavily on candy and snacks, and that’s still very much our core business. But we’re now opening the door to all the other fun products I’ve always loved. Squishies, fidgets, novelty gifts, toys, gadgets – anything that makes people smile. So yes, we’ll always be candy and snack-led, but I’d love Candymail to become the home of fun stuff.
We’re only just scratching the surface of what that could look like, so watch this space!

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: The imported snack market in the UK has exploded since Brexit / TikTok Shop – supermarkets now carry American candy aisles. How does a specialist like Candymail stay ahead when the high street catches up?

Aaron Roberts: We have to be faster, we have to be first to market, and we have to offer far more than just the basics. Supermarkets might have an American candy section, but they’re generally stocking a relatively small selection of familiar products. Our strength is the sheer depth and variety of our range, and the fact that we’re constantly looking for what’s next. We’re not just trying to sell someone a packet of sweets. We want them to discover a new flavour, a brand they’ve never heard of, or something from the other side of the world they didn’t even know existed.

I love the idea that every page on our website can be a new discovery. That’s what makes Candymail different. We’re not just a catalogue of products. We’re a place to explore, get inspired and find something exciting. And because we’re specialists, we can be much more adventurous. We can take a chance on an unusual product or a new trend without having to appeal to absolutely everyone.
For us, the fun is in the discovery, and I think that’s what keeps us ahead.

Adam Riley: If you had to pick one region, flavour trend, or product type that will define Candymail’s range in 2027, what would it be?

Aaron Roberts: Japan. Absolutely Japan! I’m completely fascinated by Japanese culture, and especially the way they approach sweets, snacks and packaging. The colours, the characters, the creativity, the unusual flavours — everything just feels so imaginative and fun.

It’s a feast for the eyes before you even open the packet, and then you’ve got all these brilliant flavours and textures to discover. I genuinely get excited every time we receive a new shipment from Japan. In fact, we’ve got another container arriving next week and I cannot wait to see everything! I think there’s still so much potential for Japanese products in the UK. Most people have only scratched the surface of what’s available, and there are so many incredible products still to introduce.

If I had to put my money on one area that’s going to be a huge part of Candymail’s future, it’s definitely Japan.

Image for Exploring a World of Sweet Treats with Candymail Feature Screenshots and Art

Adam Riley: If you could work with a specific brand for a special edition box, who would you most like to work with?

Aaron Roberts: Oooh, that’s a hard one! There are so many brands I’d love to work with! I think something like Sanrio, with Hello Kitty and all those amazing characters, would be so much fun. Imagine the packaging, the exclusive treats and all the cute little extras we could include! It would be right up my street! And knowing me, once I’d started planning it, I’d probably have ideas for about twenty more collaborations!

Cubed3 Summary

A huge thank you to Aaron Roberts for taking the time to chat with Cubed3 and share the story with what makes Candymail tick. A fascinating insight into the world of snacks (literally) and the challenges of online retail. There's a love for discovering delicious, fun treats that remains at the very heart of the brand. It'll be exciting to see what's in store! For more, visit the Candymail website.

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest