Garfield: Escape from Monday

Nintendo Switch Reviews

Garfield: Escape from Monday Review

The biggest giveaway of a millennial online is sharing Garfield memes on social media, and for good reason. Many grew up with the franchise and are eager to share it with others, including their more online-savvy children. However, as physical media and linear TV were the biggest places for Garfield through the ages, many people haven’t had the fortune to enjoy the lazy cat’s whimsical adventures and his cartoonist owner Jon.

Therefore, Garfield: Escape from Monday is in a quite interesting spot as a license game. It isn’t a franchise that will sell directly to its target audience the way other franchises would. Instead, parents will likely buy many games to share their own childhood memories with their children. For this to work, the game needs a strong hook into the franchise.

Image for Garfield: Escape from Monday Review Screenshots and Art

The good news is that Garfield: Escape from Monday gets a lot of important things in the genre right. The controls feel smooth and allow for creativity and freedom in how the player moves Garfield. The game also has power-ups that really enhance the movement, with the biggest highlight being a turkey suit that lets Garfield fly for a bit. Combined with the jump mechanics, the movement feels smooth and clever.

The level design, while a bit simple for its target audience, is still surprisingly entertaining, especially with the time-attack challenges each level offers. Here the aforementioned controls shine even brighter. Nothing feels better than blasting through well-designed platforming levels, and Garfield: Escape from Monday delivers that feeling in spades. Another lovely aspect is that the game captures Garfield and his friends’ charming personalities in delightful ways, especially through the antagonist, the evil Chef Monday, the maker of healthy food and invader of nightmares. The problem is that it doesn’t always work as it should.

One of the first grievances players will stumble upon is that the game often locks off previous sections of levels. This is a problem because each level has somewhere between two and seven hidden lasagna pieces to find. Finding these is fun, and no hidden lasagna piece ever feels outright unfair, but the only way to tell one was missed is to see the empty gap between two already collected pieces. By then, it is already too late. That means to get all lasagna pieces, the player has to replay the level, and later levels aren’t any less short.

Image for Garfield: Escape from Monday Review Screenshots and Art

While time attacks rarely take over five minutes, with a few closing in on the nine-minute mark, looking through a level for lasagna pieces can easily take twenty minutes. People don’t want to replay it. This sort of design works well in platformers with shorter levels, like Super Mario 3D Land, but the stages in Garfield: Escape from Monday are too large for a linear platformer. On its own, it’s a welcome design choice, especially since many levels feel remarkably fun to explore. However, backtracking through the entire level when the player only has a vague idea of where the missing piece of lasagna is feels painful.

It is a forgivable flaw as it only affects those looking to 100% a 3D platformer, which is far from everyone who will play the game. However, there are sadly a lot of technical flaws as well that are just bad. Sometimes attack sound effects stop playing, and in one level a vital puzzle piece despawned at the end, forcing a full replay – and yes, this included recollecting all lasagna pieces.

Sometimes attack times also feel extremely odd. Some are oddly generous, a grievance that can likely be excused by the fact that this reviewer is a former speedrunner, but the worst felt extremely stingy compared to the rest. At that level, unless the player uses a dialogue-skipping exploit, they barely have enough time to beat the stage, even with perfect intended play. It feels like it either got mixed up with another time, or a fellow speedrunner playtested it and wanted to make something that would challenge them.

Image for Garfield: Escape from Monday Review Screenshots and Art

One issue that cannot be blamed on technical issues, however, is tied to the level design itself. While all praise should go to the remarkable level designs and the different costumes Garfield wears, they do get tired. One common critique of the New Super Mario Bros. franchise is that the game loves to introduce an amazing gimmick and then run it for at most two levels. This game, though, has the opposite problem in spades.

Instead of spreading the wonderful power-ups throughout the adventure to keep it fresh, Garfield: Escape from Monday has made the curious choice to have each of the three worlds focus on one power-up, and therefore, one flavour of stage design. Just like with a lasagne, level design works best when the lasagne plates, bechamel sauce, and bolognese work together in a symphony, so one flavour doesn’t take over. Instead, it feels like one part is a full course of lasagne plates, and another a full course of bechamel sauce. It just gets stale and repetitive. By mixing up the gimmicks, they each would ironically get more time to shine. Surfing is really fun, but it gets stale after ten surfing levels in a row.

Image for Garfield: Escape from Monday Review Screenshots and Art

Ironically, Garfield: Escape from Monday gets all the most difficult parts of making an amazing 3D platformer right. The collectables don’t feel obnoxious or unfair, and the level design is fun in a vacuum. Even the controls feel remarkable. However, a bunch of minor flaws that could oh so easily have been avoided drag the game down to a painful degree. There are only so many bugs one can take before it cheapens the experience, and only so many surfing levels in a row before they feel stale and predictable.

Fans of Garfield will definitely have a fun day with the game, though, as it keeps much of the comic’s sass. Garfield: Escape from Monday will steal many a smile from fans of the comic strips and the cartoons. The issue is that the level design strongly implies the target audience isn’t people who already love Garfield and his shenanigans, but their children. Sadly, the gameplay will bore them long before Garfield’s charm grabs hold.

Image for Garfield: Escape from Monday Review Screenshots and Art

Cubed3 Rating

Garfield: Escape from Monday is in many regards a great game. The level design is phenomenal, the controls are smooth, and the game gives the player a lot of freedom. However, it stumbles on too many small obstacles to be recommendable to anyone not already into Garfield. The worst part is that, instead of spreading out the level designs, it sticks with one gimmick for ten levels straight. Lasagna is made of lasagna plates, bechamel sauce, and bolognese. This doesn't mean serving lasagna plates as a starter, bechamel sauce as the main course, and bolognese as dessert.

5/10

Average

Garfield: Escape from Monday

Developer: OSome

Publisher: Microids

Formats: Nintendo Switch, PC, PlayStation 5, Xbox Series X/S

Genre: 3D platformer

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
0 Comments
Oldest
Newest