Football Manager 27

PC Reviews

Football Manager 27 Review

If there was a good football analogy to sum up how 2026’s edition of Football Manager went for developers Sports Interactive and Sega it would be of a team struggling all year in the division before escaping relegation on the last day of the season after a last-minute equaliser. The story of FM26 is a well-rehearsed one at this point – a tale of delays, cancellations, delays, and then a product that is still to this day still sitting at ‘Mostly Negative’ for English reviews on Steam.

It was the first red card of Sports Interactive’s illustrious running of the franchise and for the first time saw major questions asked by fans about what the future looked like. Managing to get through all that and ship out Football Manager 27‘s release on schedule was a feat in itself. Managing to do it in as promising a shape as this latest release looks in its early days, though… Well, this could be a comeback to rival any match in the game.

Image for Football Manager 27 Review Screenshots and Art

In many ways, FM27 is going back to the drawing board, at least in terms of the UI. As any fans of the franchise know, half the battle is the experience with how things are laid out on the screen. Yes, the matches are important, but if the day-to-day running of a club isn’t seamless and functional, the whole thing just breaks down. FM26 introduced pop-out tiles, with FM27 dismantling most of these in favour of returning to the traditional main inbox hub and clearly labelled sections alongside it. The clear top menu on the screen is all the navigation needed. Where many found frustration in FM26 was in just navigating to locate basic functions and information.

So many times, vital things were hidden behind layers upon layers of other tiles and clicks that it just made it not worth the effort. The result of that compromise and what FM26 suffered so badly from is that Football Manager no longer taps into the role-playing immersion of the world of football and instead just becomes a monotonous grind through match after match. FM27 will feel much more familiar to those fans of 2024‘s edition. Things are so much simpler to find and do, with more information readily at hand. The upshot of that very simple tweak is that interacting with the wider footballing world becomes second nature and allows this series to show what it does best. Even basic things like each type of message having its own colour code is such a simple tweak to make it so much simpler to navigate.

Image for Football Manager 27 Review Screenshots and Art

One of those key additions to FM27 are in the training and tactical set up of teams, which more closely matches how things operate in the real world. A lot more focus has been put into preparing playstyles and tactics through the tactical effectiveness system. This covers a number of core areas such as whether players are buying into a strategy, their ability in and out of possession and their understanding. It also builds in other systems such as how thoroughly the opposition is scouted. Effectiveness matches with complexity and it has a big determination on results.

This will also change throughout a manager’s journey, as other teams combat that tactical effectiveness, and playing a certain way now more tangibly ties into a manager’s known style of play. While it can feel unfair to be punished for switching tactics and playstyles, it once again stimulates the feeling of this being a wider role-playing experience beyond just simply buying the best players and winning every match. From pre-season training to staff building, FM27 tries to make everything have much more of a cohesive purpose.

Image for Football Manager 27 Review Screenshots and Art

Despite all the marketing Sports Interactive might have done around new graphical features, the real focus that they have clearly prioritised is that immersion and world building. For example, returning the traditional cup draws and transfer window deadlines are entirely focused on bringing back the feeling of being involved in the ‘story’ of the game. What’s happening in other leagues, the best players around the world, and the key stories in football are presented slap-bang in the player’s face.

The match engine has seen several upgrades, including additional motion-captured movements that better realise the vision of modern football. Players on the pitch now physically demonstrate their levels of fatigue rather than it just being a vague stat, and there are a whole new suite of tricks, skills and movements that make things more lifelike. The pre-match presentation has also undergone something of a makeover, with new camera angles and animations adding to all the licensed banners and icons on show. The lighting system also looks very pleasing on the eye in terms of realism, and it is nice to see little touch-ups done to the crowds and stadiums. While it is far from exhaustive, there are more stadium options rather than playing in the same three or four of so many other previous titles.

Image for Football Manager 27 Review Screenshots and Art

As far as the actual gameplay innovations on match days, the main one that is really cool is the introduction of ‘tweaks’. Think of them as quick adjustments on the fly that incorporate modern football management, from wingers swapping wings to telling players to press more aggressively in specific moments. Technically, they were adjustments the player could make before manually, but it’s great to have a one-button press to do some of these key tactical plays. Shouts also fully return to FM27, having been patched in late to last year’s edition. While it’s good to have them back and the game now explains how particular shouts impact across players’ moods, it’s still all a bit of a mystery on when to use them. It would be good if the benefits and opportunities around shouts were a little more tangible.

While generally those additions and the new animations are to be welcomed, there’s still a bit of work to do on really nailing the match engine presentation. Some videos shared about the match engine still appear to show some of the classic mistakes where a goalkeeper, for example, completely misses the ball through their animation. Additionally, from early playing, there are an awful lot of low-scoring matches and a ridiculous number of corners being conceded. So far, many of the matches played have felt a little frustrating at times just due to the inability to break down defences and beat keepers. A few tweaks here and there with goalkeepers and maybe a bit more refinement on how tactics actually play out on the match engine should make a big difference.

Image for Football Manager 27 Review Screenshots and Art

Cubed3 Rating

Football Manager 27 is not perfect by any means. Some might still consider it inferior to the high watermark of FM2024. However, after the unmitigated disaster of FM26, it's fair to categorise this year as a bit of a comeback story when it comes to the series. It's clear Sports Interactive has learned some valuable lessons and got a real insight – if they needed one – about just what players of this franchise value. They value easy navigation and lots of clear information at hand. They want to be part of the world of their Football Manager save and they want that role-playing aspect. All those things are big wins in FM27. The match engine still needs a bit more work and there is lots of scope for improvement, but Football Manager 27 marks a really promising base from which to take stock and build upon.

8/10

Great

Football Manager 27

Developer: Sports Interactive

Publisher: Sega

Format: PC

Genres: Simulation, Sports

Comments

Subscribe
Notify of
1 Comment
Oldest
Newest
Anonymous
3 days ago

Feels almost disingenuous to rate this game so highly. Very few of the player base rate this game as a “comeback”. Most who have played the free trial this past week highlight the same issues with the UI and navigation. The day to day running is a headache and confusing. If you’re comparing it to FM26 then I’m sure that it is an 8. If you’re comparing it to any FM prior to this, it cannot objectively score higher than a 5. Yes the match engine may be improved, but everything else has regressed. I’m glad that people are enjoying it however official outlets and YouTubers that make their living from the game, saying that it is “back”, just feels dishonest.