Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc (PC) Review

By Luna Eriksson 17.05.2015

Review for Winged Sakura: Mindy

Few mixes of genres feel as natural on the paper as one between tower defence and JRPG. Both are about building, progressing, and micro-managing characters (or towers), however, in Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc it does show that besides sharing a lot of similarities, these are genres that also have some strong contradictions in terms of game design that clash and makes for some weird design issues. With many hours of tower defending awaiting, is it interesting enough for those that enjoy both genres?

Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc tries to take the two genres tower defence and JRPG and entwine them into a wonderful mix. This should be relatively painless as the genres share a lot of similarities in their gameplay styles. However, as shown here, they also share quite a few contradictions that sometimes create dissonance in the design, the most obvious of which is in how they are meant to be played. Tower defence games are in their very nature meant to be enjoyed in short and fast-paced sessions while JRPGs are sway more towards longer sittings. The latter element creates stages that can take 40 minutes to finish, and with Tower Defence gameplay together, it makes for painfully long stretches of repetitive action.

The reason why levels take such a long time to complete is not because they are particularly long, rather than they rely on the Strategy Pause function, which allows the player to stop the game to place towers. It may sound like a useful addition, but in reality gamers will need to become quite dependent on it to proceed, which leads to overly-prolonged sittings. Stages that normally would take around seven to eight minutes to complete turn into painfully long experiences of 30+ minutes as towers are to be placed. Sadly, this feature is almost required unless players resort to severe grinding, which in itself also takes a long, long time.

Screenshot for Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc on PC

Another major issue that contributes to this feeling of boredom and repetitive gameplay is the fact that the story proceeds forcibly slowly. The story mode could more often than not have been reduced by between 50%-75% by making some dialogue proceed more naturally and it is sometimes extremely painfully obvious that the developer dragged it out unnecessarily. The most memorable example is when all that needs to be done is survive 12 fights, almost an entire chapter, which takes around four-to-six hours. It is cheap and transparent.

It is important to mention that underneath the forcibly drawn out story mode and gameplay there is a great core that could have shined. There are several positives to Mindy's Arc, with the tower defence aspect being creative, with towers disappearing after a while, preventing that concerning situation of just sitting and waiting for everything to end, and with several abilities to use, there is strategic depth thanks to being about to develop personalised strategies while working through the content. There are also colourful characters that bring a humorous mood to proceedings, sometimes even managing to raise a smile. It is hard to not laugh when Seven, the protagonist's side-kick, gets hit by a fireball for the third time after saying that he could easily dodge them on reflex.

The JRPG aspects of the gameplay mix very well with the tower defence ones, but the pacing should definitively have been set to the faster speed of the latter genre, rather than the other way around. As it is, Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc will be too tough and laborious for most to endure, with only diehard supporters of both genres likely able to stomach the action. There is a good foundation for future releases, but the pacing issues really need to be fixed.

Screenshot for Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc on PC

Cubed3 Rating

5/10
Rated 5 out of 10

Average

The premise and concept are good to go. It is just sad that strange design choices create horrible dissonance between the JRPG and Tower Defence gameplay, taking what would have been a certain buy for anyone interested in dipping their toes into the genre and turning it into a very niche experience that very few are going to enjoy. The mix between grind and repetitive content will turn off many customers and it is sad since Winged Sakura: Mindy's Arc could otherwise have been a fantastic title and one of the best Tower Defence releases on the market.

Developer

Winged Sakura

Publisher

Winged Sakura

Genre

Strategy

Players

1

C3 Score

Rated $score out of 10  5/10

Reader Score

Rated $score out of 10  0 (0 Votes)

European release date Out now   North America release date Out now   Japan release date None   Australian release date Out now   

Comments

Comments are currently disabled

Subscribe to this topic Subscribe to this topic

If you are a registered member and logged in, you can also subscribe to topics by email.
Sign up today for blogs, games collections, reader reviews and much more
Site Feed
Who's Online?
Azuardo, Ofisil

There are 2 members online at the moment.